Body Fat% is a way off PART2

seems a bit like the "there is no problem with WIFI" on the Index 1

There are issues with the scale and its algo. The margin of error is too high.  Which benchmark is Garmin testing the results against?

This is my last 7 days and nothing is correct, if you check the values view that is nothing correct.....

Garmin are in denial. Garmin, you need to investigate against objective benchmarks and not just your beliefs. 

Samora said:

This is my last 7 days and nothing is correct, if you check the values view that is nothing correct.....

Hello! Are you able to tell me what is incorrect about the readings? Are you by chance comparing this to another device?

f|33tStA said:

as the other thread is closed by Garmin-AmberD

It can't be that the same fat value is always displayed, it can't be normal, all other values ​​change, the fat value is always 7 for every measurement, regardless of which activity class you choose?

Garmin's explanations cannot explain it in that way!

Hello, with this being on the original scale and not the Index scale 2 we need to look further into this. I have sent you an email from Garmin. I am looking forward to hearing back from you. 

thanks a lot, i already answered you! 

My S2 is perfectly accurate compared to my previous scale. 

Body fat is obviously off on S2. It shows approx 22% for every family member, while the S1 shows vastly different values, which are realistic to our real body.

It is NOT the difference between the calculation method in S1 vs S2. S2 simply shows a fake value, the body fat measurement simply a lie there.

That is sad that it does have a design flaw, but the denial from Garmin side is simply ridiculous.

Last Garmin product we bought, ever.

I also have the problem dexa and tanita consistently showing 20 -21 index s2 showing 33

• Garmin support can I ask you to fix rather then just closing the topic