Acknowledged
3 months ago

CIQ store app (iOS) falsely shows settings from *wrong app*, when two apps are installed with similar settings definitions

Connect IQ Store app version 2.30.1 (iOS)

I have a data field app that has 4 "clones" in the store. They're all basically identical except for their app UUID, app name, and certain default settings.

AppBuilder 5: https://apps.garmin.com/apps/fd690281-9c22-4fee-a81e-3b7f39aa67c5

AppBuilder 5 (B): https://apps.garmin.com/apps/706e91ae-7b84-4ac3-b0a7-dc2bcceb6fc2

AppBuilder 5 (C): https://apps.garmin.com/apps/f5259a68-1509-4ee9-9a05-46dc1d939f3f

AppBuilder 5 (D): https://apps.garmin.com/apps/394b4149-6d5a-4c2c-836d-dca71ea10b98

I had AppBuilder 5 installed on my 955, but none of the other clones were installed, and I had made extensive changes to the settings of AppBuilder 5. Subsequently, I installed AppBuilder 5 (B). When I opened AppBuilder 5 (B)'s settings in the CIQ app, it showed me settings values for AppBuilder 5, instead of 5 (B)'s defaults!

But when I added AppBuilder 5 (B) to an activity, it was clearly using its default settings values (one of the settings controls the data field label.)

Reproduction Procedure:

- If any of the AppBuilder 5 data fields are installed on your device, uninstall them

- Install AppBuilder 5 and open its settings in the CIQ store app (iOS)

- Note that the default value for "Profile 1 - Label" is "AppBuilder".  (The default values for the other apps are "AppBuilderB", "AppBuilderC", and "AppBuilderD")

- Change "Profile 1 - Label" to "Custom Label" and save settings

- Add AppBuilder 5 to an activity and note that the displayed label is "Custom Label"

- Install AppBuilder 5 (B). (Do not modify its settings or launch the app on the watch)

- Install an unrelated app, such as HM's DIY #1

- Open HM's DIY #1's settings. Exit without saving

- Open AppBuilder 5 (B)'s settings: note that the value for "Profile 1 - Label" is correctly displayed as "AppBuilderB". Exit settings without saving

- Open AppBuilder 5's settings. Exit without saving

- Open AppBuilder 5 (B)'s settings: note that the value for "Profile 1 - Label" incorrectly appears to be "Custom Label". Exit settings without saving

- Add AppBuilder 5 (B) to an activity and note that the displayed label is "AppBuilderB"

- Open AppBuilder 5's settings. Exit without saving

- Open AppBuilder 5 (B)'s settings. Note that the value for "Profile 1 - Label" is now correctly displayed as "AppBuilderB"

The same problem can be demonstrated with any of the 4 clones.

EDIT: as mentioned in a comment below, I think this is a potential security issue.

EDIT2: Simplified recreation procedure:

- install an app (B) with settings but do not modify settings or launch the app on the device. (App B's settings are uninitialized.)

- install a related clone app (A) with similar settings to B. Modify settings so that they're recognizable

- Install an unrelated app (C) with dissimilar settings to B

- Open C's settings, then open B's settings. B's settings will show B's default values as expected. (Do not save B's settings at this point)

- Open A's settings, then open B's settings: you will see A's settings instead of B's default values

FlowState
Parents
  • 3 months ago

    I'm kinda reluctant to make a video bc:

    - anyone should be able to recreate this bug given the information I've posted

    - even the process of installing apps via the Connect IQ store is such a huge pain. Sometimes instead of installing right away, an app will go into the "install queue" until the CIQ gods decide it's finally time to install the app (yes, I tried syncing and that doesn't seem to do anything). So even the process of making a short, yet comprehensive, video is not as simple as it sounds (like a lot of CIQ things)

Comment
  • 3 months ago

    I'm kinda reluctant to make a video bc:

    - anyone should be able to recreate this bug given the information I've posted

    - even the process of installing apps via the Connect IQ store is such a huge pain. Sometimes instead of installing right away, an app will go into the "install queue" until the CIQ gods decide it's finally time to install the app (yes, I tried syncing and that doesn't seem to do anything). So even the process of making a short, yet comprehensive, video is not as simple as it sounds (like a lot of CIQ things)

Children
No Data