Under Review
over 1 year ago

bug in editing settings groups

I uploaded a beta datafield to the store to be able to debug the new settings groups: https://apps.garmin.com/en-US/apps/8cfc5bd9-0835-4522-b3a0-fd3dfbfc58d2

When I edit the settings in Connect IQ Store Android the settings are "lost".

To reproduce:

1. this is my settings.xml:

<settings>
  <group id="mainGroup" title="@Strings.AppName" description="@Strings.settingsIntHrGroupTitle">
    <setting propertyKey="@Properties.hrmAntID" title="@Strings.settingsExtHrmAntId" prompt="@Strings.settingsExtHrmAntIdPrompt">
      <settingConfig type="numeric" min="0"/>
    </setting>
    <setting propertyKey="@Properties.showIntHr" title="@Strings.settingsShowIntHr">
      <settingConfig type="boolean"/>
    </setting>
  </group>
  <group id="intHRGroup" title="@Strings.settingsIntHrGroupTitle" description="@Strings.settingsIntHrGroupDescription" enableIfTrue="@Properties.showIntHr">
    <setting propertyKey="@Properties.intHrSide" title="@Strings.settingsIntHrSide">
      <settingConfig type="boolean"/>
    </setting>
    <setting propertyKey="@Properties.intHrPrefix" title="@Strings.settingsIntHrPrefixTitle">
      <settingConfig type="alphaNumeric"/>
    </setting>
    <setting propertyKey="@Properties.extHrPrefix" title="@Strings.settingsExtHrPrefixTitle">
      <settingConfig type="alphaNumeric"/>
    </setting>
  </group>
</settings>

2. start to edit settings in android

3. enable showIntHr. This will correctly (though very inconveniently*) display intHRGroup as it's dependent on it (enableIfTrue="@Properties.showIntHr")

4. enter the group settings

5. go back to the main settings (either using the left arrow in the top-left corner or by using the android device's back button)

6. you'll see that the previous changes in the settings are lost

*) I would also argue that the way the grouped settings seems to be implemented is not user friendly. I think it would be much better if the group would be displayed in the same page (in the main settings page) instead of opening them in a new page. For example when I see now the group's title, and the ">" in the right side, clicking on it I would expect to see the group settings opened below it (probably changing the right arrow to a down arrow)

See also: https://forums.garmin.com/apps-software/mobile-apps-web/f/connect-iq-store-android/289708/bug-in-editing-settings-groups

  • I agree . I first spend time figuring out the new feature, designing my solution, and then (thankfully) testing it - just to learn that people before me had already figured out it is broke. What I think is worse, is that likely some developers have not figured out that it's not working and released a poor experience which is in nobody's interest, including Garmin.  

  • Garmin, can you comment on this? It's been more than a year now that settings groups were announced but they never worked. Can you fix this? Or maybe (shamefully but less confusingly) officially remove it from the documentation? (I would be surprised if any app uses it as it never worked)

  • Same issue with my watch face. Groups just don't save in IOS. This makes this functionality completely useless. Glad I tested with a debug version first.

  • This is also a bug for my App - PLEASE fix right away - the new grouping is useless as long as this defect is not fixed 

  • Of course, it's obviously a good one, that's why many developers want to use it now. What I said is that Garmin shoot themselves in their foot by announcing this. Nobody would've missed it if they wouldn't....