Share App Without Making Public

Hi there,

I have a small problem where I'm trying to continue development on an app for my wife and a couple friends to use. The app uses some screens that are similar to another one (fully admitting as such) but more customized to our liking as well as different feature sets and is set to free (hoping that this wouldn't be stealing from their profits).

The only reason that the app is on the connect iq store is so that we are all able to download it, keep it in sync, and so that the custom fit contributions get passed into the recorded activity session.

The developer of the other app has reached out now asking me to take it down due to similarities between the apps otherwise they'll report it (rightfully so) and so this leads me to two questions:

  • How can I release the app so that it's not public to the general audience and only people I want to link to it?
  • How different does that app need to be / is this something I can work with Garmin support on?
  • It's all or only you.  You could send people sideloads, but then no app settings or fit contrib data.

    The one you have to work with is the other dev to see if they think it's "different enough"

  • I had a similar problem a while back. I developed a data field that was supposed to be tested by a select group of users.

    Here’s what I did:

    I published the data field in the Store—making it accessible to everyone. However, I chose a meaningless name, added meaningless images, and mentioned in the description that it was for testing purposes—without specifying what it was actually about.
    In the settings, there was a field for a password. Without a password, the message “Request tester status” appeared on the empty screen. No one ever asked for it.
    My actual testers knew the password, of course.

  • I think the answer you need is multi layered:

    1st - and this is the bad one, the other Dev can report it to their hearts content but does anyone really think Garmin will even take notice of the request let alone take action on it? - No to both

    2nd - do something like mcinner1 has stated, and I would say you don't even need the password or message. If you want to hide it from the other Dev then create a different account (or use your wifes details). Your app will soon get buried under all the AI slop that frequents the store these days and no one will ever find it unless you want them to.

    I know this is not the moral high ground but its the society / ecosystem that we frequent, so you do what you need to - and good luck

  • There are a lot of great ethical points in here but the reality is that software is not protected - design can be, algorithms can be, names and logos are but there is really little new under the sun.

    I started to get wound up recently when a developer mimic an application I had spent time on. But that in reality creates competition and that increases quality. And difference is what makes things different!

    Something may look similar but have a higher refresh rate, better quality data, higher precision etc - without trademark or patent protection (see above, very difficult with software) the CIQ ecosystem is no different to iOS, Windows etc… want AI to make a new PhotoShop? Adobe can’t do much about it.

    This will wind a lot of people up but it is reality and just this week another new entrant turned out an app-a-day with things like Refill etc duplicating what is in the store and I really can’t see what or why or how it can be changed.