• Replies 15 replies
  • Subscribers 18 subscribers
  • Views 832 views
  • Users 0 members are here
Options
Related

Menu2InputDelegate.onSelect not triggered on touch devices in SDK 8.4.x

the-ninth

I recently upgraded to SDK 8.4.0 and then 8.4.1, and for the first time tested touch-based devices such as the Venu 4 and Vivoactive 6. On these devices, Menu2InputDelegate.onSelect no longer seems to be triggered when tapping a menu item.

I am using CustomMenu, not Menu2. On button-based devices such as the Fenix series, this still works as expected, even when interacting via touch rather than buttons.

Switching back to SDK 8.3.0 resolves the issue, which makes this look like a regression in SDK 8.4.x.

So far, I have only tested this in the simulator. I do not have access to real touch-based devices, so I am not sure whether this is a simulator-only issue or also affects physical devices.

Is anyone else seeing this behavior?

  • in reply to the-ninth

    Thanks for the quick response. I've had some users report similar issues though, including one user who sent me a video of being unable to select a menu item.

  • in reply to SirLancelot
    SirLancelot said:
    Thanks for the quick response. I've had some users report similar issues though, including one user who sent me a video of being unable to select a menu item.

    Hmmm, that is concerning then. I do not have one of the affected devices myself, but I was in touch with a user who does, and he did not experience the issue.

    In my app, the CustomMenu is a core part of the UI, and without it the app is essentially unusable. So I think I would have heard from other users if they were experiencing the issue as well.

    Are you using Menu2 or CustomMenu?

  • in reply to the-ninth

    I use a CustomMenu with the Menu2InputDelegate. My user had an ApproachS50...

    Thankfully in my case, the option most users want to click is the last option, so it seems the app is somewhat usable for them. But still, it seems weird.

    I also don't think I own any of the affected devices...  



  • in reply to SirLancelot

    Ok nevermind, I do own one of the affected devices. I tried the VenuX1 in sim and it had the weird behavior where you have to click the bottom button to unlock the menu. Tried on my physical VenuX1 device and everything worked. So I don't know...

  • in reply to SirLancelot
    SirLancelot said:
    I tried the VenuX1 in sim and it had the weird behavior where you have to click the bottom button to unlock the menu. Tried on my physical VenuX1 device and everything worked.

    Glad to hear that. I have no idea, though, what your user with the Approach has been experiencing...