I think for you to start to get a meaningful answer, you'll need to provide more information. Such as when you say 'search' is this when you search for the name of the app or do you mean in the store lists?

Maybe provide a link to the app.

And provide extra info e.g. you have searched the forum already for answers, and understand how the store lists work - this will give people who might be able to give you some pointers the concept that they are not doing all the work for you and you have invested time and energy into this already

First of all, thanks for the quick reply. Of course I tried to find an answer to my question, but unfortunately I didn't. If you need any further clarification of the problem from my side, I will be happy to provide it, here is the link to the app (data field): apps.garmin.com/.../4e040b4d-731a-4471-9a49-bcae06b6f914

The link comes up with 

Sorry, this page is currently unavailable.

So I think you need to contact the connectIQ team Brandon.ConnectIQ Kyle.ConnectIQ

Thank you! I'll write to them

While the app was approved, has your trader verification been completed?  See https://forums.garmin.com/developer/connect-iq/b/news-announcements/posts/trader-verification

You are charging for the app, so you must be a verified trader for it show in the store.  It's different than being able to use Garmin Payments.

Yes, I suspect this is the problem. But nowhere in the interface is there any notification or red/yellow flags as to what exactly I should do. Followed your link and got a green notification in the ‘Developer Dashboard’ ‘Your information has been successfully submitted. The review process usually takes 1-3 business days, and you will be notified when it's complete. During this time, some platform features may be temporarily restricted until verification is finished.’ Now waiting, thanks!

And it's the weekend, so the clock won't start until Monday in Kansas..