Why has "Find my phone" stopped working?

The "Find my phone" feature used to work fine, but it seems to have stopped doing so.  As a test I can have the phone right next to me, and it even connects to my Garmin Connect, but if I click the "Find my phone" feature it shows "Waiting for phone" then shows "Connected" and that message stays there.  If I press the "Find my phone" button again it says "Connection Disabled."

The Connect app does have phone permissions allowed and everything between the phone and Garmin Connect seem to work fine except for just the "Find my phone" feature.  Also, both my phone and 935 both have no issue connecting to my WiFi.  Any ideas?