This discussion has been locked.

You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Beta 12.2. Training effect calculation is wrong!

Training effect calculation is wrong! After the update, this indicator began to be considered incorrect relative to the past similar workouts. Today I did exactly the same workout as last Sunday, but the clock showed me a completely different indicator and load. why? what affects it? average heart rate and pace are the same. the current training was even shorter in distance, 20 km, instead of 24 km last Sunday, but the load is shown more!!! I didn’t even run into the anaerobic don, but the clock showed that I was there. Here are screenshots of two workouts.

0 FlipStone over 3 years ago

Welll:

avg pace of 5:05 and HR already around 160 after 10-15 minutes in the first

avg pace of 4:49 and HR around 160 after 45-60 minutes in the second...

I see plenty of difference which would have an effect...

(A difference of over 15 seconds in pace is not 'the same'and in the 2nd you see your HR starting lower and climbing up later while in the 1st it's higher already earlier on... So the same avg doesn't say it all)

0 rklyukin over 3 years ago in reply to FlipStone

yes, but where did the anaerobic effect come from in today's workout? I didn't even run an anaerobe today, judging by my heart rate zone.

0 parentoft over 3 years ago

Hi there

Please you the beta-forum for beta issues.

Thanks

0 DPSK over 3 years ago

I think the same bug on 745 that someone mentioned on reddit.

Why would Garmin import a faulty algorithm?

www.reddit.com/.../

0 andreef over 3 years ago

I created a beta program bug report for this. I'm seeing the same issue on a recovery run with HR all in zone 1 is giving me Tempo as primary benefit with training effect of 2.9 aerobic and 0.1 anaerobic.

0 rklyukin over 3 years ago in reply to andreef

Please click the + sign on this topic to rank it higher in the general bug list.

https://forums.garmin.com/beta-program/forerunner-955-series/public-beta-bug-reports/i/bug-reports---beta-12-20/training-effect-calculation-is-wrong

0 rklyukin over 3 years ago in reply to DPSK

Please click the + sign on this topic to rank it higher in the general bug list.

https://forums.garmin.com/beta-program/forerunner-955-series/public-beta-bug-reports/i/bug-reports---beta-12-20/training-effect-calculation-is-wrong

0 kcobb2001 over 3 years ago in reply to andreef

Yes there is something to this, just posted about a similar issue in the beta program 955 community forum. Z2 run categorized now as VO2 Max under 12.20 ...

I also bumped up the bug report

0 Garmin-Kevin over 3 years ago

All,

Please follow progress of this report in the main thread:

FR 955 Series: Training effect calculation is wrong on 12.23 software