HRV reading

Hello Garmin team and fellow users,

I’m a Forerunner 255 user on firmware version 23.20, and I’ve observed a troubling pattern: my overnight HRV has dropped significantly — suggesting infection or physiological stress — yet my resting heart rate (RHR) remains completely unchanged.

From both personal experience and physiological norms, an actual infection or systemic strain would typically present with **↓ HRV + ↑ RHR** (usually +10–15 bpm). The fact that only HRV changes, while RHR stays stable, is inconsistent with expected bodily responses.

This appears to be a **measurement anomaly**, possibly due to:

- Optical sensor artifacts (e.g. poor contact, movement)

- Algorithm changes in fw 23.20 altering HRV calibration

- Lack of internal cross-check between HRV and RHR

Other users have reported similar HRV-related issues post-update (↓ HRV with normal activity levels) .

**I therefore ask:**

1. Could Garmin investigate whether fw 23.20’s HRV calculation might be miscalibrated when RHR remains stable?

2. Consider implementing an internal **HRV–RHR consistency check**—if HRV drops without RHR change, flag it as potentially unreliable.

3. Provide users with a quality indicator or warning in Garmin Connect when HRV data shows signs of artifact.

Appreciate the excellent products and continuous improvements—just hoping we can refine this important metric.

Thanks,

Johnny Andersson

  • You can be sure Garmin will never check that for you in your life. Your HRV can easily change if your sodium/potassium balance changes, your hydration, mental stress etc. The correlations are much more complicated than what you write. Garmin has to deal with much simpler technical problems.

  • I wouldn't hold out much hope.  My HRV scores are much higher than they used to be.  My range was 50-65 and now it is 68-86.  I've not changed anything, and I just am not that concerned about it.

    If they were going to put their resources into fixing the algorithm, it would be for the Body Battery metric which is so inaccurate (for me at least) that I only use my watch at night 3-4 times a week.  On days when I feel incredible, I wake up at a 71-80.  On days when I feel a big groggy I am in the 92-100 range.  

    Good luck, but I enjoy the Garmin I have, but am doing things based on how I perceive I feel and not how they tell me I am.