This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Does Heart Rate Dynamic Source Switching Work with a compatible ANT+ Chest Strap from another brand?

I buyed a chest strap few weeks ago to improve my heart rate monitoring in sprinting, intervals, etc where the optical heart rate lacks of accuracy, my question is, if the chest strap is not garmin but its ANT+ compatible, will work this new feature between the watch and the chest strap? thanks in advance

  • Unfortunately, Garmin keeps its source switching criteria secret. Therefore, if the question is whether to receive bad data from OHRS or not receive any data if the strap fails, I choose the second option and simply turn off this strange function altogether.

  • Hello, thanks, i will turn it off and will give a test, best

  • The wording similarities between what Garmin now calls 'Source Switching' - the old function of OHR taking over from a totally failing strap - and 'Dynamic Source Switching' - the new _extra_ function where OHR suppleants/tries to correct bad data from a strap, is unfortunate.

    I have not installed the new update on my FR955, but if the option to turn off DYNAMIC Source Switching simply is called 'Source Switching', then do turn that off for anything else than a few modern Garmin straps. This to prevent, or at least try to cut off, an extra bug pathway...

    There is a thread in the FR955 forum containing relevant information:

    HR Dynamic Source Switching - what is the point?

    https://forums.garmin.com/sports-fitness/running-multisport/f/forerunner-955-series/373025/hr-dynamic-source-switching---what-is-the-point

    But if you just want a direct link to a Garmin support page - bad wording and all - here it is:

    What is Heart Rate Dynamic Source Switching?

    https://support.garmin.com/en-US/?faq=Nf8r6ApX4d9lX0G0flEsVA

    Edit: Remembered that some people rather want straight facts than links to facts, so here are the pertinent words from Garmin (at this date):

    "Switching sources based on the quality of the heart rate signal during an activity requires the use of a Garmin HRM-FitTm, HRM-ProTm, or HRM-Pro PlusTm heart rate monitor along with a watch from the compatible watch list below."

  • "The optical heart rate lights  will remain on with this feature enabled" - I have that "feature" disabled. But in activity my OHRS still flickers parallel to the connected external strap.  And i have a third manufacturer ANT+ chest strap. If my strap is not a plus-pro-mega a_little_bit_overpriced garmin strap, Source Switching should be disabled automatically, right? But it doesn't work like that. Just another immature innovation.

  • Where do you find the setting? 

  • Heart Rate Widget , Settings (Top Right Button)

    Source Switching as a toggle option there.

    Also via main menu (see link)

    support.garmin.com/.../

  • Thanks, I found it. Didn't think about checking the widgets.

  • I disabled it, and then gone to run, and after analyze the fit file I see that there only one heart rate graphics, because heart rate and external heart rate are just the same value, so maybe the lights are on in the watch but the values getting is only from the external chest strap

  • I have immediatly turned off this feature "source switching" .

    I dont even understand what this is.

    A heart rate strap is ALWAYS more accurate as the garmin optical heart rate sensor.

    The garmin optical heart rate sensor is OK during rest and sleep, but during training is absolutely inaccurate.

    The garmin optical sensor is simply extremly weak quality.

  • the optical heart rate monitor in the forerunner 255 is very precise, i buyed this watch after seen tons of reviews of diferent brands, for steady runs is very capable if its wear in right condition, but for sprints and high speed impact trainings is not the best no matter the brand of the optical sensor, but because of the vibrations and strong movements in the arms when doing strong and fast movements in strides, sprints, hit, etc its lacks accuracy, its common sense, i buyed the chest strap to have a more accurate readings in anaerobic trainings