Garmin tempe sensor discontinued! Alternatives? Perhaps Ruuvi sensor?! Come on Garmin, give us the Tempe sensor back!!!

Because Garmin unfortunately discontinued the Garmin tempe sensor (bad move, Garmin!), I looked around what maybe could replace the tempe sensor. I stumpled about the Ruuvi Sensor (the sensor is using an bt connection), which is available with different functionalities (2in1 (temperature, motion), 3in1 (temperature, humidity, motion), 4in1 (temperature, humidity, pressure, motion): Ruuvi - Ruuvi and I found a widget from a iq developer for serveral Garmin devices: Connect IQ Store | Watch Faces and Apps | Garmin

In theorie the widget/app (not availabe to add to the widget list) should look like this on the wearables:

  

but it looks like this on my F8xAmoled:

I have already written to the developer, but there are some comments and this issue seems to exists longer (?). Although it was only recently added for use in the F8 series. He will try to fix it with the next build. Update (fixed): forums.garmin.com/.../1875256

The developer has provided the code, maybe someone can develop something, maybe even a data field (with all the data)?

The Ruuvi sensor is a real beast compared to the Tempe sensor and has 36 grams (Tempe about 9 grams)- but for attaching at a backpack, it would be ok for me. 


You have your own little personal weather station with you (if it would be displayed properly on the Garmin wearables).
Ruuvi has its own app for the iPhone, where you can even set alarm areas for the various sensor functions.
    
So I will use it while hiking connected to my Iphone (I have 2 Garmintempe sensor left for my wearables). The Ruuvi seems to be intended for stationary mounting (two screws for mounting are included), but I will give it a try while doing a hike etc. Why do they make the sensor cover also black? I have paid € 53 for the 4in1.
.
Btw: Temperatur accuracy:
.
Ruuvi : absolute accuracy ±0,1 °C, output resolution 0,01 °C (see specs in Ruuvi link above).
Garmin Tempe: within 1 to 2 degrees (https://support.garmin.com/en-US/?
.
For clarification: the Ruuvi sensor values aren’t integrated into the activity files. Therefore I think we need a iq data field with appropriate programming.
  • Former Member
    0 Former Member 9 months ago in reply to Tisztul_A_Visztula

    I was thinking about something that would functionally resemble a Stevenson screen in miniature. It's been years since I experimented with the idea. I did measure (with a decent thermometer) in paper and a plastic enclosure, but I forgot what the outcome was. The thick white paper thing I made was difficult to mount, I basically had it trailing from a cord held in the hand. Awkward and not practical. How far will I go to just have temperature registration, that is only accurate to 1 degree (in the FIT file), I said to myself, this is going too far. So for years I made cuts in the underside of the fabric of a light colored hat's visor and shoved a Tempe inside. The fabric of the cap would sweat soak in minutes, so the Tempe was measuring a kind of 'wet bulb' temperature. Compensating for the radiant warmth from my head, I reasoned. Never measured accurately if this was the case.

    I like the idea of a modified white plastic cap. I wonder if a silver painted cap would be better, reflecting more.

    If only I had more time to play with these ideas!

  • Just going back to visors, I have 2 piieces of the previous version of this cap   https://www.compressport.com/inter/en/caps/753-running-cap-for-summer-7640314045903.html and they have reflective aluminium stripes. But even these caps did not give me those results I wanted.

    The miniature Stevenson screen was much better provided you wore at least a thick waistbelt, but ideally a small running backpack or a bigger hiking backpack. If not then I had to rely on the cap visor, but the total weight and size of this gadget was too big to combine it with a visor. And really awkward. :-)

    Anyway even a mini Stevenson screen can be warmed up after a while in direct sunshine if it is behind your back and not in front of you , at least it is what I think. The total amount of air flowing through it seems to be too low compared to the total volume of the solid outer material. If it is iin front of you much higher amount of air can be streaming through. That means the necessity of a pretty long visor :-)

  • So for years I made cuts in the underside of the fabric of a light colored hat's visor and shoved a Tempe inside. The fabric of the cap would sweat soak in minutes, so the Tempe was measuring a kind of 'wet bulb' temperature. Compensating for the radiant warmth from my head, I reasoned. Never measured accurately if this was the case.

    Using water/sweat is an interesting idea, but since the humidity of the air is changing too much from day to day, and typically even within a day, the cooling effect of the evaporation is also far from being constant. Anyway you may be right that the humidity has effects at least in the same direction, if it is less then both the evaporation around Tempe is bigger and from your head more sweat can come off, thus more radiant warmth.

    I am just not sure how you could manage to have a naturally wet visor, because as I remember I never sweat so much that my whole cap including visor become soaked.

  • My main use for Tempe has been to see lowest night temp etc. for backpacking. I see on Ruuvi's website that the sensor itself has temperature logging, but does the ConnectIQ app currently support it, or does it just show real-time measurements? 

    And you are right, the larger size is not ideal for carrying it with you. As it's name suggests ("Ruuvi" means "a screw" in Finnish), it's meant to be screwed to a wall.

  • The cig app is only showing real-time. Someone has to develop a new app and a data field, also for getting the temperature stored in the activity file…

    Yes, the Ruuvi is actually designing for stationary use, but I was looking for possible already available/usable alternatives for hiking.Wink

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member 9 months ago in reply to Tisztul_A_Visztula
    I am just not sure how you could manage to have a naturally wet visor

    The caps are extremely cheap thin (polyester I guess) and in summer it is usually quite humid so evaporation isn't quick. That, and I do indeed sweat like a pig. I avoid the gym because I spent half the time wiping whatever poor appliance has the bad luck of being my choice for cardio. Sorry for being gross! 

    BTW I store one Tempe outside and grab that for use during runs, so it is already acclimatised to the outdoor temperature. 

  • Well since I have just :-) 3 Tempe and I use one for both hiking and running, I leave it on the last place I mounted. And quite often I dont start my runs from our house.It is why I asked the developer of “Tempe field”  ciq df to add a delay parameter for the use of current data for min/max/avg.

    Btw today I bought 5 plastic cream jars in 3 sizes to produce the new version.

    I even read about insulators and later I am going to buy some en.m.wikipedia.org/.../Aerogel, if it is available in small pieces, too. Because it is quite expensive.

  • I feel some new motivation to manufacture a Tempe shield ver 2.0.

    Jeez! The cover part of the largest jar was ok, but  the bottom was so thick that it was prone to crack. After I bought  and ruined two of them I had to buy  the same volumetric jar, but from another pharmacy. It had smaller top and height which created a lot of problems during the manufacturing. So I swore to all gods that I would never fabricate a version 3 unless version 2 would be perfect and version 3 would be a simple replacement.

    I had no patience to drill nice holes or cut  nice curves with scissors.

    2 pics of the top half of the Tempe shield, 2 of the bottom part:

  • And the nice looking small basket Snow White is holding in her dainty hand ;-)

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member 9 months ago in reply to Tisztul_A_Visztula

    Pretty and elegant ;-) I like your design.

    Much better to make than what I have in mind now; a variation of this weather station screen, but far smaller and with only 3 'layers'. Currently busy turning the house over looking for thin white thermo-plastic material that I can cut into round shapes, deform using hot water to make convex saucers, then cut the center out and hot-glue them with something I need to find, to act as spacers. Yoghurt containers come to mind. These deform in the dishwasher at 70 Celcius. Maybe spoons would work as a mold. Or is this a good excuse to get a 3D printer?