Solar ring color - is one better than the other?

My first 7X Solar Sapphire developed an issue where it ended up in an infinite boot loop, and had to get sent back to Garmin. I found another one locally at a store, and before I got a chance to send the old one back to Garmin, I was able to compare them side by side. These are the exact same model watch. Old one on the left, new replacement one on the right.

You can easily tell the solar panel on the old one was a lot redder, and the new one is a lot yellower. I assure you, it's not due to different viewing angles, the solar panel on the new one is substantially yellower at all viewing angles and in all light.

I asked Garmin if this was something I should worry about, and they essentially said "no", and said it was probably due to different viewing angles (it isn't). Anyways, not knowing which one was better, or whether it even made a difference at all, I just let it go.

But in the 2 days I've been using this new one, it seems like it struggles to get very much energy from the sun. This is a screenshot of my watch after driving to work this morning - the bright morning sun was hitting it directly during the entire drive, for 30 minutes - the watchface was perpendicular to the sun, and my window was down so it was not in between the sun and my watch. You can see, it got VERY little energy from the sun. When I did the same thing with my previous 7X, it would net 10-15k Lux hours. This time it barely got 1k. And I noticed the same thing yesterday, walking around outside in the sun, that it barely seemed to take in any energy from the sun at all.

Is it possible that the yellowish version of the solar panel just sucks? Should I return it and try to get another one with the reddish solar panel? It seems like my first 7X solar worked vastly better than this replacement one I got.

  • Dude you buy all these or you just return them and they give you another one every time?

    I'm asking because the one time I had to return a Descent Mk1 that was not working as it should out of the box... They put me to wait about 3 weeks.

    That happened in Greece last year , finally they accept that it had a problem (HRM didn't work) and I payed some extra to buy the MK2 this time

  • The observed color variations in solar panels are a natural result of the photovoltaic manufacturing process. These variations do not impact performance but can result in slight variations in how the solar panel looks depending on the lighting.

  • I think we all here agree with that.

    But we wonder what is the manufacturing process that results in redness and what results in yellowness...

    Here we are a skeptical group and we don't want only to know if it's natural but also why is happening and what's the slightest difference in the process that creates that difference.

    Difference in colour means difference wave length of the reflected light and that means difference in material and/or structure of them...

    Please explain us with a technical and detailed answer about why I see a red and a yellow screen and solar ring at this photo!!

  • If you live in Kansas, you can try either getting a job at Garmin or storming their offices demanding answers from their engineers. But don't expect technical and detailed answer to your question on internet forums.

  • I'm sure that's true, but I definitely observed that the yellowish one barely had any solar charging capability, while the two red ones had easily 10-20x better solar charging ability.

    It might just be a cooincidence, since after all I only have a small sample size of 3 watches which isn't enough to draw any conclusive results, but I can definitely say for certain that for whatever reason (maybe related to the color, maybe not) the one that had a much yellower color did a substantially poorer job of solar charging.