This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Venu 2 doesn't count Norwegian floors

I just ran 30 times up and down the stairs.FLOORS COUNTED: 4.

I have tried this several times before, but the Venu 2 doesn't count it right. I've been in contact regarding this earlier, but no update has fixed this issue yet. 1 in 5 floors are counted as I ran 100 and only 20 was counted 

Even three types of cheap Fitbit counts my stairs flawlessly, why can't Garmin make this happen? (*Garming support team getting triggered to fix this*)

Different ways I've tried to get it to work:

1. I have tried the floor climb workout with and without GPS.

Same result. Counting 20% of the floors.

2. I have checked the general floor counter, same result.

3. Slow climb works better, but why would I go slow?

Where Fitbit gets it right:

Fitbit measures climb with the accelerometer, and accumulate every meter inclined during the day. Whenever you pass the threshold for a floor(3m), one is given and the count starts over.

Example: 1/2 a floor +1/2 a floor later = 1 floor 

(We can discuss if this is the correct way of doing it later, but at least they get it right)

Suggestions to why Garmin can't count floors?

1: my ∆floors makes for a 273cm climb. So if the threshold for a floor count is 300cm and the internal counter doesn't accumulate climbed centimeters, I'm really just going 0, 273, 0, 273, 0, 273 and will never have a single floor counted. 

Fix: use accelerometer and accumulate every climbed centimeter.

2: I believe the Venu 2 is using the barometer to check altitude, and the update frequency is horrendous. If I run up the stairs and check the floor count, I have to wait approximately 8-15 seconds before the number is updated. So if it takes a reading every 20 seconds, the altitudes will be read at random heights between 0 and 273 cm, making no sense to the softwaree and rewarding zero floors 

3: Norwegian floors aren't tall enough.

A typical floor would be 270cm in Norway. Ceiling height is normally 240cm and the building materials adds 30cm resulting in a total of 270cm. If the programming says a floor is 300cm, it will only count it if I walk the floor, then raise my hand an additional 27cm.

4: let me disable gps and barometer forcing the floor climb to be calculated by the accelerometer.

For everyday non-workout floor counting, use accelerometer.

5: reduce a floor to 250 cm.

Point being: We have 265 days of rain a year, I need this floor climb to work indoors...

  • 3: Norwegian floors aren't tall enough.

    Raise the hand above the head for a few seconds at the top, and touch the floor at the bottom. That should easily make the difference.

    4: let me disable gps and barometer forcing the floor climb to be calculated by the accelerometer.

    Accelerometer cannot be used for the elevation. Even if you had a gyro (and many models do not have it), it still could not be done any better than with the altimeter. Not even close. The accuracy would be very miserable. The wrist worn accelerometer is already pretty inaccurate for very simple axial continuous movement on a flat plane. The accumulation of hysteresis errors at floors climbing (permanent up and down acceleration changes close passing through zero) would render it useless even with a chest strap (much less directions of motion) , not speaking at all about the built-in wrist mounted accelerometer moving on even more complicated and chaotic curves.