FWIW I uninstalled Google Phone which reverted the the firmware version and now the notifications work. Seems something Google changed in their latest app update broken notifications in Garmin Connect…
I was able to install this version to get notifications back:
Google Phone 31.0.241960258 April 26 2019
Same results here. Downloaded from APK Mirror. Thank you.
It has to do with a 6/5 update to the Google Phone App. If you uninstall the update, notifications will resume again. At least they did for me. Google Pixel 2 XL with latest security patch.
I also notified Garmin and sent them diagnostic information. I was having the issue with the Garmin 5 and the Fenix 3 HR. I went to the Google Pay store, and uninstalled the Phone App. It did not actually uninstall the app, it just uninstalled all updates to the app. After doing this, I am receiving phone call notifications on both devices. While not a perfect solution, it is a temporary fix until a) Garmin figures out the problem or b) Google issues an update to the Phone App. For those of you that are still having issues, did you try uninstall the Phone App from the Play Store?
So sorry! Two errors: 1) Garmin Fenix 5 and 2) Google Play Store *NOT* Pay store. My bad - good catch.
Just created another thread on this as I didn't see yours only 10 below mine (sorry!). It's definitely due to the update as I saw some on Reddit with the same issue.
The lack of support by Garmin is terrible. I used to have a GPS unit for my car and they were always so great back then.