ActiveCaptain vs HomePort

The Garmin HomePort application has been discontinued: support.garmin.com/.../

The replacement app is Garmin ActiveCaptain where waypoints and routes can be managed using Navionics maps on a either a phone or tablet.

In my opinion AC should only be a backup solution to HomePort as complex editing of many waypoints and routes are way better performed either on a desktop or laptop computer.

Complex waypoint and route management requires:

  • A large high resolution screen
  • A keyboard (for naming waypoint, routes)
  • A mouse for precise marking of waypoints
  • Waypoint and route folders and lists
  • etc ...

Another area of concern is that AC requires a peer-to-peer WIFI connection to the chart plotter to update its maps. With a bluetooth connection was not used for this purpose (maybe transfer speed issue)?

WIFI peer-to-peer connection requires a lot of steps:

  • To turn ON WIFI on the chart plotter
  • Disconnect from your current WIFI network on your phone or tablet
  • Connect to the chart plotter WIFI SSID with your phone or tablet
  • Perform the map updates
  • Disconnect from from the chart plotter SSID on your phone or tablet
  • Reconnect to your WIFI network on your phone or tablet
  • Turn OFF WIFI on your chart plotter

To summarize, given the identified weaknesses of AC,should Garmin develop a desktop/laptop HomePort replacement to interact with the latest generations of chart plotters / fish finders sonars?