This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Observations upgrading from 520 to 520 plus

Here are some notes of the differences and annoyances I've found going from a 520 to a 520 plus. They might be helpful if people are thinking of upgrading. I've been happy with the 520 apart from the recent firmware/battery life fiasco, but I liked the idea of extra storage so I didn't have to keep loading/unloading different area maps

Disclaimer: I've only had one ride but some stuff is definitely not fully baked yet. I didn't use navigation at all, just used it as I would a normal 520 minus maps.

Firmware 2.50

In no particular order:

Setting up is a total pain - I didn't want to copy the 520 files so I set it up manually - Took about 3 or 4 hours to copy all my screens and sensors. The only nice thing are the new layouts for some of the screens (some bigger data fields)

The reminder to press "start" when you're moving doesn't really work - you only get the notification if you are actually in the ride screen - not at the "home" screen.

Temperature is way off, maybe 5 degrees C too high

Speed is a bit odd too - I have a speed sensor (wahoo) but speed seemed to bounce about all over the place 36km/42km/36km all whilst cruising at the same speed in full open cover. Was basically useless. Don't know if it just ignored the speed sensor ? Didn't happen with the 520

I stopped subscribing to Strava a year or so ago but you get 60 days free with the 520 plus - so I signed up again. It wanted a credit card but simple to immediately cancel and delete the credit card. A bit of a waste of time because the one segment I did sync to the 520 plus didn't trigger. This worked fine in the 520 (even yesterday - as if you unsubscibe it doesn't remove the segments) . If you're into segment bagging the segment screen looks a lot better though - you can have loads more fields...assuming it works.

Etap pairing is problematic - it has a very aggressive timeout - and it's jut notifies you every minute or so that it's reconnected - get's very annoying, very fast. This didnt happen on the 520. Ended up unpairing it a few minutes into the ride.

You can now have 10 IQ datafields but still the same number of total slots for apps/widgets/data as the 520 so a bit of fail there IMO

Battery life seems about the same as the 520 (didn't use navigation !)

The out front garmin mount they supply is the long 1030 style one with a light mount on the bottom - not quite as neat as the original 520.

backlight - still the annoying double press - first one to get the backlight % (who's idea was this)

GCM on the iphone has a different (better) interface for the 520 plus - you can initiate a sync like you can with the 5x - there are also audio cues for navigations and laps etc.

Some things, like powering down, require a confirmation - so extra button presses. The Confirm/cancel options have a little arrow on them...which is better as I was never sure which I was doing. You can't cancel a power meter calibration by pressing "return" you have to select cancel and ok. Lots of the extra button presses are annoying.

Notifications are still text and phone only - not whatsapp or anything else you might use.

I still use a Tanita weight scale - but that seems broken - it gave my body fat percentage as 7% - the 520 gave it as 16% (which is consistent). Probably something to do with "athlete mode" but
you can't set that on the 520 Plus. Irrelevant anyway as it didn't actually sync back up to garmin connect, no matter how many times I initiated a sync in GCM

Still has the 20 sensor limit

It looks quite good in the all black :)

TL:DR

Make sure you buy from somewhere with a good returns policy, I'm not sure the annoyances and bugs are worth the mapping, especially as the standard 520 can basically do mapping anyway. Happy to answer questions if anybody has any and I'll update this when I played with it a bit more.




  • I have the same issue you have with your Etap on my Shimano Di2. It keeps reconnecting sporadically during a ride. Gear mode also keeps popping up from time to time. My D-Fly is right next to the 520 Plus. No issues with Di2 on my Fenix 5.

    I also have a Wahoo speed sensor on the front hub, but have not noticed the issue you're describing.
  • also have a Wahoo speed sensor on the front hub, but have not noticed the issue you're describing.


    Mine is on the rear hub - maybe it dropped out - zero problems on the normal 520 however. Might have a dig around with the fit file repair tool to see.
  • I recognize two problems (so you are not alone):
    - Temperature is way too high
    - backlight - still the annoying double press - first one to get the backlight % (who's idea was this). Maybe they should change single and double tap?
  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 6 years ago
    I just got my 520+ to replace my aging 520.
    - Elevation profile screen is still useless - no zoom. Whoever chose the scales has never ridden up an actual mountain.
    - Map zoom is still a UI disaster. It takes 7 presses on three different buttons to change the scale.
  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 6 years ago
    Yes - forget about zooming while on the bike. I prefer to think that you'll have to pick an optimum zoom level that you like and stick with it. That way you'll know what details you'll be getting and not getting.
  • Transferring setup files from 520 to 520 plus gives big head start on setting up data fields. All my sensors with custom labels and data screens mapped over perfectly from 520 to 520+. As commented here it took him 3 or 4 hours. Took me 15 minutes tops. Of course I’ll have to go back and explore the new layouts, but up and running in no time by copying the settings.fit, etc files into NEWFILES on the 520+. I’d recommend backing up first though to play it safe. P.s. when I called Garmin to ask if the transfer was doable, they advised against it (of course).
  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 6 years ago
    So that's the trick with the backlight... thanks.

    New to this forum. Here are the annoying issues I have with the 520 plus. I use it strictly for navigation, no ANT or other sensor functionality.
    -Cannot turn off virtual partner. I've set if to off but still get annoying notices about "updating vp" or "vp finished". Set speed to 0mph and still finishes before me.
    -Can only view two pages of cloud routes. Says, eg, "p2 of 8" but the scroll at bottom only advances to p2 and not further. Sometimes its 1 and 8. I have to keep the cloud routes cleaned up and remove or unpin files from rwgps and route course, which are what I use.
    -Takes a while to recognize a route if you start in the middle somewhere. Has accurate map but turn directions stuck on the first turn at beginning of route.
    -Some of the "accept" actions using the select button do not work, for example, with auto-re-route set to "prompt", does not accept "yes", similar with turning off live tracking. Had to kill it from within Garmin Connect.

    I dont have a problem with the fixed route profile. tickmarks every .4mi seems reasonable, if the vertical scale is a bit arbitrary.

    One other thing-is is possible to access full text messages from the unit? I just get the first line.

    Overall I have been happy with the unit.
  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 6 years ago
    I should clarify that my cloud routes are all on route course. Not sure if that may have something to do with it the pages issue. I did have to install a beta version of this app when I had a select button issue with the original app.
  • Still with the Virtual Partner???
    Oh for F***'s sake. That thing has to go!