This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

BLE or ANT+ for dual sensors?

Former Member
Former Member
My Garmin speed sensors obviously transmit ANT+ only. However my power meters and heart rate monitors are all dual ANT+ and BLE. Is there any reason to pick one over the other? I don't see any mention of one using more battery than the other from the transmitting device. It looks like ANT+ records once per second, while the BLE transmit many times per second (but the Garmin device I think still only records once per second?)
Aside from the power meters, I do see that the Elite HRV app states my Wahoo Tickr needs to use BLE to record meaningful Heartrate Variability. So I suppose I''ll use BLE for that, but unsure about the rest...
Unless I hear otherwise that HRV is useless or only good for those that really know what to do with it (which I don't yet). I see that Garmin adds an option to record this data, tho I've not tried it.
Lastly, I pretty much have to disconnect my phone to be able to use my Garmin Remote (due to known Bluetooth issues that will, at this rate, never be fixed). Has anyone found that this also applies to BLE sensors? It's not caused issues for me yet to use a power meter in BLE mode while having the remote attached.
  • I don't know what power meter you have, but the current BLE spec is pretty limited in comparison to the ANT+ spec.

    The BLE spec supports power, cadence and power balance. It does not support auto-zero.

    The ANT+ spec supports, power, cadence, power balance, Torque Effectiveness, Pedal Smoothness, auto-zero and Cycling Dynamics.

    The other major difference is the network configuration. ANT supports a many to many configuration so you can have multiple things collecting the ANT data.

    Most BLE sensors can only support talking to one device at a time. So if the power meter is talking to the Edge over BLE you cannot also have it talking to Zwift at the same time over BLE.