This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Heart rate and afib

Former Member
Former Member

I have afib, which I luckily can convert back to normal rhytm by running. I get afib maybe every 2-3 weeks, which I then convert back by running.

When running, my heart rate is very high, it can typically be 180-220. This is not entirely "true" though, because I can have some fast heartbeats and then some skipped one. So it does not feel like 220 - but it is tougher than normal because my heart is not pumping blood optimally.

My conversion procedure is to run with a quite slow pace, and watch my hrm. It will vary between 180-220 bpm, but "suddenly" it will drop down to e.g. 155-165 and be very steady around that. My heart has then converted back to sinus. I then run for e.g. 5-10 minutes to make sure "it sticks" to sinus.

I've been using a Polar V800 as hrm, which has worked brilliantly. Today was my first "afib conversion session" with my new 945. The 945 proved to be "useless" for this purpose - somehow it seems that it "error corrected" to much, so it never showed the high heart rates. It only showed like 150-160 bpm, which made it impossible for me to see when my heart converted back into sinus. It was the same behaviour both from wrist and external HRM-Run monitor. I had to change back to my Polar watch to be able to read the high heart rates.

I saw the same behaviour when reading the heart rate from my wrist also when not exercising. When in afib, my heart rate goes fast to 140-150 just by walking, but the 945 did not show this. It showed around 100 bpm. even if my heart rate was higher when e.g. just walking.

My Polar V800 and an Apple Watch I had both showed correct (and high) heart rates, but the 945 somehow did not read the afib rhytm very well.

Any similar experiences or comments? I am very happy with my 945 for exercising, but it seems that I need to keep my Polar for afib conversion, which I rather do not want to do...

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 5 years ago

    Same. I have fast afib, where it doesn't last more than 5 minutes per occurance, and probably occurs once every couple of months. Happened yesterday while wearing the 945, and it did not register.

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 5 years ago

    Well, OHR works by registering changes in blood "transparency"/color due to a change in hemoglobin oxygenation. This happens when oxygenated blood is pumped through the body after ventricular contraction. Atrial fibrillation doesn't do any real pumping (if anything, it works a bit to the contrary). So OHR won't register it - and it is correct. Some traditional HRMs working on ECG principle presumably incorrectly identify atrial fibrillation as a ventricular contraction. That's what you've been seeing. You won't see it with OHR.

  • I have the same experience sadly.

  • Is it a good idea to rely on a consumer device to deal with a medical condition like this?

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 5 years ago in reply to Former Member

    I would at least expect the external hrm strap to register my increased heart rate. I actually have an increased heart rate, (with increased rate of ventricular contractions), which also can be felt by manually measuring the pulse (with my fingers) and by a ECG device I have. Apple Watch optically correctly read the high rate - 945 does not. 

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 5 years ago in reply to CloggyAbroad

    I am not using the 945 to deal with the condition. I am dealing with the condition by my running procedure, which I have discussed with my GP. I am using the watch to tell me the correct pulse. This is the basic purpose of the 945 - which it seems not to do properly in this case. 

  • Nope - I have a very useful medically approved ECG device!

  • Former Member perhaps worth loading the latest beta, and if it still is the same feed in their feedback form? My wifes apple watch picks the higher HR up correctly, as does a Polar OH1 - so OH can do it