This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Firstbeat: Sleep Quality Assessment - nice to have

As great as it is to have many helpful Firstbeat metrics licensed on the 945, one that I really miss is the Sleep Quality Assessment https://www.firstbeat.com/en/consumer-feature/sleep-quality-assessment/

It is an interesting metric taking into account the actual quality of sleep and restorative effect - a bit more advanced and precise as what body battery is offering.

The current sleep analysis is nice, but fairly useless without quantitizing sleep quality - e.g. unless you are a medical expert it won't help you to know how much time you spent in what sleep stage or how long your sleep was correlating with how well you actually rested.

I wonder if there was a distinctive decision skipping that feature or if it simply was overlooked and forgotten - which means it could possibly be added with a firmware update.

Woud love to hear your opinions about that.

Top Replies

All Replies

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 6 years ago

    Garmin appear to be quite keen on continuing the development of their own sleep tracking technology, so I doubt we'll see them switch to this licensed FirstBeat metric unless there's a significant market demand which they're unable to meet with their own dev.

    I do agree with you though in that I'd love to be able to use this metric.

  • yes I could I could sell my oura ring

  • Of course the more firstbeat algorithms the better :) 

    But on the other hand, if I understand the metric correctly it's just the same as body battery.

  • Doesn't body battery do what you need?

  • Nope, it is definetely not the same as Body Battery as it is aiming in a different way: while Body Battery is an all-day stress accumulator which can also recharge without sleep, the Sleep Quality metric focuses on how well you actually slept, basically interpreting what you can see in the  sleep function inside Garmin Connect, but also quantitizing it to a number from 1 to 100.

    That is something Body Battery cannot provide: if you had a very relaxing day, your Body Battery score will already be quite high when you go to bed and during sleep it will generally fully recharge, even if your sleep was not perfect but just average.

    And Sleep Quality Assessment would exactly tell you that: it starts its assessment when you start to sleep and stops it when you awake, so that's the score only measured during your sleeping time.

  • If body battery says you're fully loaded, what does it matter if the sleep was 70 or 90?

    How would you use that figure and what benefits would it give you over body battery?

  • Because Body Battery is not exact enough to tell you if your sleep was good enough to do a really tough workout today or better try something less stressful. This mainly depends on how well you recovered over night and how your sleep affected your training performance on the next day. This is something that Body Battery does not provide, it just tells you in a very general way how much stress you have had over the last hours and when it is time to take a little rest. But it is virtually useless just after waking up to decide if this is a tough training day or not.

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 6 years ago in reply to HUMODDA
    This is something that Body Battery does not provide, it just tells you in a very general way how much stress you have had over the last hours and when it is time to take a little rest.

    Very true. A little while back, I had a bad case of heartburn that kept me up tossing and turning all night long. I may have gotten 3 1/2 hours sleep. In the morning I just laid on the couch and watched TV. Because I was just lying around, that afternoon Body Battery gave me nearly a full charge even though I felt like crap from lack of sleep. 

  • That would be helpful to have - agreed.