This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Respiration, Pulse Ox, Sleep Tracking....ALL useless on this watch.

I've had this watch now 6 months or so, and thought it was just me so did a lot of searching and found the Pulse Ox, Respiration, and Sleep Tracking on this (and pretty much every) Garmin watch are useless.

They're so wildly inaccurate, for instance I tested the Pulse Ox while at the doctors (which he let me do 3 times kindly) and it was off by 8-12 each time!

The Respiration I wont even waste my time talking about, when doing yoga or breathing exercises the watch seems to think im breathing as if im going for a jog. And this is after sitting there and purposefully breathing steadily to let the watch try get my rhythm.

And the biggest issue with this watch...sleep tracking....I've resorted to using a a Xiaomi Mi band ($35!!!!!) it can track by itself when I nap during the day along with sleep at night and accurately tells me when i get up or am moving a lot. It also positively tracks when I go to sleep, as sometimes I lie in bed for an hour or two. The Garmin....cant do naps, cant accurately tell when you've gone to sleep (if its before what your settings are for bed time then forget about it), doesnt properly track when i have a bad sleep, and when im lying in bed after waking up it doesnt track ive woken.

Don't get me wrong the fitness aspects of the watch are great, the battery life is excellent....it just fails in every other way outside of tracking GPS activities. 

  • I agree fully.

    Sleep tracking and respiration are terrible, very unreliable and often inacurate. It is surprising to see that other smart warches with lower price and not oriented for sports, are so much better at sleep tracking than Garmin watches. Big fail!

  • I still cant believe the sleep tracking is based off of something as arbitrary as setting a sleep/awake time in settings. And it doesnt even work that well anyways. The VA4 cost a lot and is really put to shame by budget fitness trackers, those trackers are even coming with GPS now....the only reason I've really stuck with the Garmin so far is the extra statistics you get, and a solid battery life and ability to access all the data (for export). 

    sadly the times ive forgotten to start tracking my exercise....the mi band has auto detected and tracked my bike ride! The gap really is very narrow for my use cases.