This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Vivo 4 Heart Rate measure accuracy depends of the activity selected

Former Member
Former Member

Hi,

I'm playing Squash but unfortunately it does not exist in the Garmin world, so I had to select other activities to record my games.

I noticed the heart rate measure on my Vivo4 is very dependent on the activity I select compared to a chest belt and the record of the hear rate with my phone during Squash (which is i guess difficult to track due to high hear rate and quick variation while playing and between playing and resting between games).

If I select Cardio as the activity, the Vivo4 reading, and heart zone % are reasonably coherent with what I got with the belt. The Vivo4 does not capture the quick increase of HR during games or decrease of HR during rest very well, but I would say it's usable, see figures recorded yesterday:

Belt : Average HR: 136, Max HR: 162, 33 % in Zone 5, 44% in Zone 4
Vivo 4: Average HR: 136, Max HR: 158, 22% in Zone 5, 63% in Zone 4

If I select another type of activity, like Running without GPS or Running Indoor to measure my activity during Squash, the HR measure and Zone % are much lower and completely off compared to the belt and not usable, see figures recorded today:

Belt : Average HR: 133, Max HR: 171, 29 % in Zone 5, 37% in Zone 4
Vivo 4: Average HR: 120, Max HR: 139, 0% in Zone 5, 13% in Zone 4

I got the impression the HR real time measure is smoothed off and peaks averaged to remove what the watch considers as glitches, but the end result is that it's way below reality and inaccurate for Squash.

I think Garmin should investigate this and propose a solution.

How do you submit a bug to support ?

  • I dont have a belt, but using the heart rate meter on the gym equipment i also found similar results. Running on treadmill etc Vivo 4 is under estimating the HR and cardio it is over estimating. 

  • Apparently the watch calculates HR differently depending on the activity selected.

    support.garmin.com/.../

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 5 years ago in reply to RunnerM

    Ok, but then what is the activity to select if playing Squash or Tennis?

    I could not find any native Garmin activity for that in the Vivo4.

  • Maybe try different activities to see which one seems to perform the best (Cardio?) and then create a custom activity named "Squash/Tennis" based off that one. (go to "Add More" at the bottom of the list of activities and then select activity you want to copy based off of).

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 5 years ago in reply to RunnerM

    Thanks, I'll try to find one

  • Please post your results Former Member. Squash is my main activity and struggle to find an activity that correctly records my HR. Tried the Squash app in Connect IQ but didn't like the results.

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 5 years ago in reply to Bhabob

    Beside Cardio I could not find any activity to track HR reasonably ok with the Vivo4 wrist sensor when playing Squash, you can only hope this will change in future updates.
    I'm wearing the watch quite tight and under a wrist band to protect it so I know it's not moving when I'm playing.
    Using the HickingDF4 2 data field with the Cardio app you can get the steps count there while playing but unfortunately the info is lost when you close it.
    Note that the free version beeps you every 10 minutes, I'm using it as a reminder to drink :-)

    If you really want to track your HR correctly during squash, you'll need to use a Ant+ Cardio chest belt coupled to the watch.
    Then any activity would be ok, and the Squash app would also work.
    When i'm using the belt, I use indoor running so I can get the step count in the report in the end.