This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Trailforks - lack of details so far on what is actually included

Former Member
Former Member
I'm really surprised so far that Garmin is releasing this soon with so FEW details on how the Trailforks data actually works, or how it actually LOOKS for that matter. The only screenshot I've found is here.
https://www.pinkbike.com/news/first-...computers.html

To me, it looks like they're overlaying the Trailforks basemap data on top of the standard OSM cycling map for Garmin.
I've been doing this same thing already by donating $15 per state to local trail orgs and downloading them from Trailforks. They offer a transparent version and I throw it on top of the garmin maps. I've just not been super crazy about this because the trails more or less follow 'closely' to the OSM trails and can get cluttered with duplicate text from each source (TF and OSM).
The screenshot above looks like it's just doing the same thing. Not that that's really a 'BAD' thing, but in my case I just want to verify if it's the data I already have access to.

The trailforks non-transparent basemap downloads I've downloaded from them actually look much cleaner, but they lack the OSM maps that haven't made it to Trailforks yet. That's a no-go for me as I need those old-school trails listed in OSM (already in the Garmin basemaps) that haven't made it to Trailforks yet. That's why I was eager to try an Edge 830, but if it's no different than overlaying maps the way I've been doing on my 1030, then I'm not sure I see a point in down-sizing. There just isn't really any footage out there on what the maps look like.

For reference, Garmin support has told me they do *not* plan to bring the Trailforks data to the 1030, which is why I was looking to switch to the 830 in the first place.
So this leaves me in a bind as to weather or not it's even worth switching. Because the new 530/830 features *other* than Trailforks integrated data should eventually be on the 1030 anyway.
--
So let's assume I decide to go ahead and get the 830. The lack of legit details out there is pretty confusing for consumers. See below.

The wording on Garmin’s own sale page:
mountain biking model has integrated Trailforks data
--This implies the stand-alone unit may not have it??

The wording on CleverTraining’s sale page:
All Versions: MTB dynamics (no mention of Trailforks) .
Bundle Only: mountain biking model has integrated Trailforks data, including trail difficulty ratings
Mountain Bike Bundle Only: integrated Trailforks data includes trail difficulty ratings
--So based on this, it would appear that the stand-alone 830 / 530 do *not* come with Integrated trailforks data.

But according to DC Rainmaker, this data *does* come on the stand alone unit.
This is what was explained on his forum.
A) Trailforks CIQ App (same one as last year) – remains as the core way to get info from *your account* to the device
B) The Mountain Bike Dynamic Metrics are available on all units as-is (530/830, bundle/no-bundle)
C) The Trailforks trail/map data are available on all units (530/830, bundle/no-bundle)
D) *However*, on the non-bundle Edge 530/830 you have to do a one-time ‘unlock’ by simply signing in once with a Trailforks account (free, throwaway one is fine). It’s done once, and there’s no visible tie on the unit itself. My guess is that this is how Garmin knows how much to pay Trailforks on a per-device basis.

If this is the case, why has Garmin not made this clear? I've even reached out to them to ask them to clarify this, as the product page REALLY needs to be updated for the public to know exactly what they are purchasing.
I mean, if they can't even get the product details right on launch or give resellers the correct details on a 400+ dollar computer, that's pretty surprising.

Can anyone from Garmin chime in on this and just confirm for those of us on the fence, that the stand-alone unit does come with everything in the unit that comes with the bundles? If so, the store-front really needs to clarify this.
  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 6 years ago
    I've gone ahead and cancelled my pre-order. The more I think about it, I don't want to down-size the screen from a 1030 as I mainly use this for navigation.
    Aside from the smaller screen, the 830 looks like a great device, but I'm going to stick with the 1030 and continue building my own maps if Garmin does not bring Trailforks over to it.
    It'll be interesting to watch this forum and see if the 530/830 resolve the Phone connectivity issues that to this day plague the 1030. (having to uninstall/resinstall, unpair, re-pair, etc etc every week or two). I think that alone is another reason I'm not going to be an early adopter here.
  • I have "stand-alone" unit - TrailForks map is preloaded but locked. You need to unlock it once with your TF account. On the software that was otriginally loaded I was getting error when trying to unlock the map (it promted me to unlock when going to "MTB Trail Navigation"). Then the SW got updated to 3.20 and the menu and TF map were unlocked.

  • One cool feature on the 830 is that when I stop on a trail it automatically shows the map.  No scrolling required.  Not worth an upgrade but just something I noticed.

    The integrated features with downloading routes from Trailforks is very convenient.  I select a ride, add it to my wishlist, and it's available as a course.  This is pretty sweet.

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 6 years ago

    Summary - 

    Trailforks is included on all versions (bundle or not). 

    This comes as a separate transparent map with colored lines that stack on top of the existing city maps.  This is not 'built into' the city maps but you can turn it on/off to overlay it. 

    You can 'donate' on Trailforks site to download these same maps (per state) to get them as overlap maps like this, or a full city map without OSM maps if you are on an older device, such as the 1030.  Altho it probably won't do the following. 

    I do like what Garmin has done in that it has all the data overlaid.  Originally it would get too crowded as it shows both Trailforks maps and the same (OSM) maps.  

    Garmin has updated the firmware so 'MTB' ride mode to essentially clears out all the OSM data if you are zoomed into the map, so it's easier to read the trails.  You must zoom back out to see the OSM data (which is still important).  This could be handy in issues where Trailforks only has a few maps and OSM has more data (not common but it happens).  Tho it can be a pain to zoom out to see that data, I can't really think of a better solution aside from an on-map toggle button.  But I wouldn't really expect stuff like that to get implemented as that's just one user's idea. 

    I thought the above update was a BUG or faulty map at first, then I read the release notes and it ticked.  One of those "oooh I get it" moments. 

    Keep in mine, if you run your own custom maps (topo, etc...) the Trailforks map networks will clear out any of those graphics when zoomed in.  It only does this where the maps exist.  Think of tracing the Trailforks maps with a poligon layout.  Anything within that shape will clear out other maps once zoomed in, while you can still see the other map data outside of the Trailforks maps area. 

    Again, zooming out then renders all maps. 

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 6 years ago in reply to Former Member

    I don't think any of the map options let you specify the zoom level where this occurs.  If anyone knows otherwise I'd be interested to hear.