Undismissable alerts covering the screen - please fix the UX

In many situations Edge 1050 pops up a banner at the bottom of the screen that won't disappear automatically. This banner covers portion of the map containing user current position and immediate surroundings.

In turn this destroys situational awareness - you don't know where you are and where your next turn is. This is a very bad UX and can be even dangerous in certain situations. This got progressively worse with firmware updates as more and more such warnings started to pop up.

Garmin - please understand that there are many situations where one can't click away a prompt especially that many of those just reappear immediately without end. In the terrain I'm riding to let go of handlebars means to stop and is unrealistic to expect. Same goes for heavy traffic I need to get trough every day.

Simple use case example:

As of 2023 (+/- a year) EU requires all new cars to have assisted driving systems. Part of that is implemented via onboard radar. This means each time such car passes me by Varia radar will display undismissable 0:9 error code covering bottom 1/3 of my map. Even if I make an effort and dismiss it next car will just trigger it back.

This makes navigation using Edge 1050 practically impossible. I don't know when I'll be robbed of my situational awareness next which adds to overall stress and high workload of driving in busy traffic.

What should happen to be considered good UX:

1. All notifications should have timeout and disappear automatically. I suspect some notifications have to stay for legal reason but try implement this as much as you can. This way if someone is completely overworked in their cockpit (traffic, flying down narrow mountain trail at speed, etc.) there's still a good chance to get position view back

2. Buttons on Edge Remote, electronic shifters and similar devices that would trigger a function on Edge 1050 should contextually dismiss notifications first. This way at least it's easy to just 'click away' the banner regardless if you can let go of the handlebars.

3. Map screen should reflow in a way that bottom of the map is not covered by the anything in any situation. Exactly as when you add data fields on the bottom of the screen. Same should happen on all other screens. This is what all competitor devices do in such cases. Smaller map with position still visible is much better than bigger map that does not show where you are.

  • I can second your critics and your proposals to avoid the distractions of sticky and repeating messages. Messages should not cover the map at the bottom and should have a timeout so that they disappear automatically. It would be very helpful, if the Edge remote has more buttons to program and as such I would certainly add a dismiss message function to my remote. The reason to buy the remote is to keep your hand on the handle bar, however dismissing a message requires everbody to touch the display. This is potentially dangerous.

  • In additional, Garmin, it would be great if you make possible to dismiss alerts by first pressing AXS/Di2 buttons on hoods instead programmed  function. 1st click -dismiss, 2nd - programmed function. Only when pop-up alert exists on the screen

  • Yes, please! Notifications, Hazard warnings etc. are useful. But only if we can get rid of them easily. I 100% second the idea to make the first button press on the remote dismiss all notifications / pop ups.

  • Garmin doesn't care about your safety; every generation of Edge devices require increasingly more taps to use the device because they design the UI as if it was a phone. I think of it as an ever-increasing "tap tax".