RESOLVED: HR Zones Keep Getting Changed

Every few weeks when I do a workout and look at it in Garmin Connect, the HR zones have changed for no apparent reason.

This has just happened again now, I did a workout yesterday, and it correctly used my auto-calculated LTHR-based zones as it has for the last few weeks, I've done another workout today and it's used different zones. Even though settings on my watch still shows that the zones are set based on LTHR, from the values shown in GC it looks like it's reset them based on HRmax, but not using its default percentage ranges. I do also have an Instinct 2, but this is also synced to use LTHR to define the zones, and I haven't even used it between workouts. Plus, I can go for weeks on end swapping between both devices, normally without issue.

As I've done previously, I've reset the zones on both watches and resynced them with GC, but there's no way of showing whether they'll be respected until I actually start another workout. Previously it's taken several days of constantly resetting them before they've 'stuck' - as I say, even though the watch will show prior to a workout that the zones are set based on LTHR, using a HR zones data field during a workout shows that it's not using those.

Here's what numbers it should be using, and the random ones it changes to which just seem to be 10% chunks of HRmax

(RHR 53, LTHR 178, HRmax 200)

Zone Range LTHR-based Random
1 56-66% 116-141 100-119
2 67-78% 142-157 120-139
3 79-89% 158-168 140-159
4 90-100% 169-177 160-179
5 101-112% 178+ 180+

This really messes my stats up, for example you can see that at 140 bpm I am in Z1 but it'll be recorded as Z3 so my easy aerobic recovery sessions are getting logged as threshold when this happens.

Anyone else seeing similar?

  • This explains why my long run was z3/z4, besides the zones on the watch were correct. So I can confirm this with 16.22 Fenix7 s ss.

  • RESOLVED: After a lot of time today struggling with trying to make my watch 'keep' my zones, much swearing and several restarted workouts, I finally resolved this for me. In GCM I noticed that a specific 'Sport Rate' for cycling had randomly added itself, and looking at it the zones it had set corresponded to the random ones I reported above. I've never used these custom sport zones, so why this one just appeared in the last few days is beyond me. I've now deleted it, and it seems to be back to using my proper HR zones again. So I now need to add this to the other things I have to check haven't got messed up from time or time or after every update.