Just wondering if you had an outcome?
Hello!
I have exactly the same problem on my Instinct with the BACK(SET) button. It does not click at all, is harder to press and sometimes you dont know if you have pressed it or not, as mentioned by more of you. I send it to Garmin under warranty. They gave me brand new watch with nice buttons. After about 3 days, the BACK(SET) button gets broken again and is now exactly the same as on the first watch.
Not sure what to do now. Im supper happy with the functions and looks of the watch but this is annoying.
This is why I'm reluctant to send mine back. The ABC button doesn't click, but it always registers and it doesn't stick. Actually, if I hold the watch up to my ear and press the ABC button in the right place, I do hear a click. Garmin support asked me to either send it to them or return to Amazon, but I'm afraid that I'll get one just as bad or worse. As long as the button doesn't completely die in the future I can live with it.
There is a lot more discussion about this problem on the FR 945 forum, so it's not isolated to the Instinct.
I have the same problem, but with the back/set button. Based on the responses of others, this seems to be a common problem, so I think it's something I'll have to live with. I'd be afraid of this or another issue happening if I get a new watch under warranty.
Did your buttons ever break? Or what happened ?