My connections cannot see my activity, even though I have set the activity privacy to 'My Connections"

My connections cannot see my activity, even though I have set the activity privacy to 'My Connections".

I have searched through settings and I can't figure out why this isn't working.

I also checked and made sure my previously tracked activities are set to "My Connections"

Either there's a software bug, or things do not work in a way that you would expect them to!

Would appreciate any suggestions.

Thanks