Activity Points have stopped working (Fenix 5X)

Tonight is the second time I have noticed a change in my Fenix 5X's behavior of either not recording, or under-recording activity points during a cycling event.  

Over the past several months I have discovered that the only way to get 'credit' (activity points) saved to GC when recording the activities on my Edge 830 is to also wear my Fenix 5X during the ride (but NOT record the activity via the watch activities).  The approach causes the F5X to auto detect the activity and start recording the actiivity points.  This behavior seems to have changed in the last week or two!

Tonight, I went for an outdoor ride and had all my sensors connected to my Edge 830 (speed/Cad, Power, HR, etc)-all of them, BTW, that have been connected to the F5X in the past as well.  I rode for 65 minutes at a casual pace (average HR was 134 bpm), temp was cold (29F avg, 25F min), in the dark.  F5X was on my wrist, securely held to my arm by the watch band, and further held secure by my jacket.  The HR was recorded, as can be seen below:

As you can see below, there is no 'auto-detect' activity that took place.  However, the Edge recorded and uploaded the activity just fine on it's own (like it normally does-I start and stop the activity).

Would it really be too much to ask for Garmin to commonize their 'ecosystem' and just simply assign activity points to activities recorded on an Edge device also?  I kind of sense a bias from all the badges assigned to running (a ton) vs. cycling (a moderate amount).  Is this bias also in effect to not assign 'activity points' to Edge-based activities?  I wish the Edges were generate these points because most times cyclist wear a much more reliable source of HR data (strap) so the integrity of the data and 'activity' is much more accurate than the wrist-based HR of the F 5X (and others).

Anyone else see this issue?  Any suggestions?

This wasn't a problem at all through the months of July - September.  Why now?  What changed???

Sean

  • What is an Activity Point?  Please state question clearly in a few words.

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 5 years ago

    The best way to guarantee that you get intensity minutes would be to record the activity on both devices with the sensors, especially the chest HR strap, paired to both. That's what I do and then I simply discard the activity from the Edge and let the one from the Fenix sync so there aren't two activities in Connect. While I realize that this isn't necessarily an ideal solution it does work.

  • Yep, on both devices.  Just did another 1-1/2 hour ride in the cold today and ZERO intensity minutes assigned.  WTH Garmin, quit breaking your functionality-serioulsy!  This used to work just fine...

  • So I just tried this today (recording on both my Fenix 5X and my Edge 830)-the result: I got about 20 minutes worth of intensity minutes for a 1:40 ride with an average HR of 141 (both devices connected to my HR chest strap).  

    I can't help but think there must be something weird with recording Intensity minutes out in the cold weather because this seems to have gone haywire since the temps have dropped.  Additionally, I get about 20 minutes worth of Intensity minutes when I'm scrub my hair in the shower!  No, I'm not scrubbing the whole time-the elevated temp and my residual elevated HR (post ride) are seemingly enough to register 'Intensity minutes'.  

    How ironic (and frustrating)!

    So in short, it appears that you will get ZERO intensity minutes if you regiister a bicycle ride at all!  This is turning my Fenix 5X into an expensive gimmic!  I bought this stupid watch to do only a few things: 1) track sleep 2) have a GPS unit I can use while in the woods (hiking, XC Skiing, etc) 3) register collective activity and 4) have as a backup cycling computer if I forget my Edge at home.  I'm certainly not seeing the value in this decision.