What is the difference between "Route Planner" and "Course Planner" applets?

What is the difference between "Route Planner" and "Course Planner" applets?  And what does that mean in practical use?  And if the differences don't matter, why are there two applets?

Short Answer:

The question above led to a long thread after I posted it in 2022.  Since then, forum managers started pointing other threads here when they ask the same question.  In summary, Garmin uses the vocabulary "route," "track," "course" and "activity" to describe what are all generally the same thing.  Namely, each is an ordered set of 3D points (lat, lon. elev.) that defines a path relative to the Earth's surface.  So the simplest way to understand them is to consider how they vary from one another.  

Routes and tracks verses courses and activities

The difference between routes and tracks on the one hand and courses and activities on the other is the data format in which the points are stored.  Tracks and routes are stored in a .gpx format, which is an easily transported universal standard.  You can open a .gpx file in text software like Word or Notepad, and the data sort of makes sense.  Courses and activities are stored in .fit format, which a Garmin proprietary format that is highly compressed (needs less storage space and makes no sense if you open the file in a word processor) and can store additional information like heart rate generated by Garmin devices that's not part of the universal .gpx standard.  I'm nto sure, but I believe the compression is accomplished without loss of resolution.

Tracks and activities verses routes and courses

The difference between tracks and activities on the one hand and routes and courses on the other has to do with how they are created.  If you define the ordered set of points explicitly, say when you're planning a hike, Garmin calls that a route or a course.  If a Garmin device creates the set of points based on its location, then Garmin calls that a track or an activity. An obvious consequence is that points in routes and courses don't have timestamps, whereas Garmin devices timestamp the points the devices record.

The differences matter because (and only because) they affect how you manage your navigation data.  In a perfect world, there would be only one word for all four concepts, and users would be asked to distinguish what they want when they export or import navigation data.  But like most high-tech things, these terms developed over time.  So possibly for backward compatibility, Garmin continues to use all four words to keep things simple for long-time users, even though that makes things painfully complicated for new users.  In an attempt to minimize the pain, Garmin hides some of the distinctions, but that means users can be surprised and upset when what they've created is not what they meant to create.  It also means that users can have a hard time finding their navigation data in a Garmin device if they don't understand how and why Garmin uses so many terms for what are all basically the same thing.

Caveat

I'm not an expert.  So there are probably mistakes in the above.  I hope they are minor and don't defeat the purpose of sorting out the main confusion.

  • I guess there are two, because Garmin could add them inexpensively.  

    Basically, the Route Planner comes from Garmin's automotive GPS world.  It assumes your current location is the starting point.  All you need to do is add a destination and then the device calculates the route. The file type is a gpx file. which is a traditional GPS file type. POI's are traditionally used with this type of functionality.  If you have an automotive GPS within your vehicle, it likely has POI's (points of interest to drive to).

    The Course Planner comes from Garmin's fitness watch GPS world, so the file type is a fit file. The starting point and destination (and any other intermediate points) have to be defined by the user. Since this is traditionally being done for fitness, the destination is typically your starting point, because you're going on a jog or a bike ride or some other fitness activity and usually returning to your starting point. 

    From a website/phone app perspective, you would use Garmin's Explore website/app with the Route Planner and Garmin's Connect website/app with the Course Planner.

    So the 66i can act like a handheld automotive GPS and like a bulky fitness watch GPS (as well as a traditional hiking GPS).

    If you want to find a local service use the Route Planner and POI's.  if you want to setup a workout regime and pre-define your intended course, use the Course Planner.

  • Thanks, Like2Hike.  Do you know what the difference is from a practical standpoint?  Setting aside the multitude of overlapping apps and web sites that Garmin has not been able to integrate, assume, I'm just using the device.  From documentation, the only difference I see is that the course allows for a mix of trail-routes and direct routes, which would be handy in the case where the map being used has a missing trail segment.  Is there any advantage to using the course planner that you know of?

  • I think it's a matter of using the right tool for your intended job. I see the Route Planner, the Course Planner and Saved Tracks as three different tools...so the question is, what do you want to accomplish? 

    To me, the Route Planner and POI's are the best tool to find a local service...a restaurant or lodging or hospitals.  Just like an automotive GPS.

    Courses are designed for fitness, not finding a local service. However, in practice, the Course Planner is just like the Route Planner except the file type is different, and one has to define the starting point for the Course Planner.  Within the 66i, there is no advantage to using the Course Planner, that I can identify.

    If you want to share files with someone, then you need to know what file types can be accepted by whom you're sharing with.  The Route Planner is gpx, and the Course Planner is fit. So the advantage would go with whichever file type you need to share with someone.

    As a hiker, I don't use either the Route or Course Planner because when I hike, I'm not trying to find a local service or define a fitness regime path.  I use the Saved Tracks.

  • There is no oourse planner icon in my 66i

  • Go to the Main Menu, and then press the Menu button. You should see, "Change Menu Order", and press the Enter button. Scroll up lightly and you should see "Add Page". Press the Enter button and select "Application". You should find the Course Planner there. Select it and it will be added to your Main Menu.

  • Thanx very much. That was the answer. Just received a replacement for my defective warrantied 66i that didn't have latest update or features. Your suggestion helped to rectify my problem.

  • The main difference:

    Routes are created based on a given "map". It will only contain a few turn-by-turn warnings points based on the current algorithm used to route your destination. So it is COMPLETELY depend of the used map. If you use a route on a device with a different map it may or may not have to be recalculated and sometimes it leads to an endless loop...

    At the other hand courses are not dependable on the map it was created. It's more like a track but with several turn-by-turn warning points and it does not depend of any map. It will work even without any map. Courses can have a tcx (for old units) and fit file format fro the new ones.

    GPX tracks does not support turn-by-turn warning points.

    This article can explain it better: Export File Formats – Ride with GPS Help Center

  • At the other hand courses are not dependable on the map it was created. It's more like a track but with several turn-by-turn warning points and it does not depend of any map. It will work even without any map. Courses can have a tcx (for old units) and fit file format fro the new ones.

    This is not entirely correct. There are two ways how the GPSMAP 66i can navigate with a course: Direct Path or Roads & Trails. The former works like a track (with optional course points), as you describe. The latter works like a route: the unit will use the active map to adjust the course to follow roads & trails of the map.

    This is also explained in the article that Garmin-Leslie linked to (What are Tracks, Routes, Waypoints, Activities, and Courses on Garmin Outdoor Handhelds?).