Vivosmart 5 the Best Fitbit in 2025 | Expert Recommendations

I’ve been researching the best Fitbit options over the past few days because I want a reliable fitness tracker to help support my health and activity goals.

After reading expert reviews on Wirecutter (NYT), Consumer Reports, and watching a bunch of tech YouTube channels, two models keep coming up as top recommendations:

 

Garmin vívosmart® 5, Fitness Tracker

https://www.amazon.com/Garmin-v%C3%ADvosmart%C2%AE-Fitness-Tracker-Long-Lasting/dp/B09VY63659

Garmin vívoactive 5, Health and Fitness GPS Smartwatch

https://www.amazon.com/Garmin-v%C3%ADvoactive-Fitness-Smartwatch-Display/dp/B0CG6NR413

I’m mainly focused on tracking daily steps, heart rate, sleep, and workouts. I also want:

  • Solid battery life

  • Comfortable wear throughout the day

  • Built-in GPS (for walks and outdoor runs)

I don’t really care about music storage or voice assistants.

If anyone has personal experience with either of these—or just solid advice on which might suit me better—I’d really appreciate your input.

Thanks in advance!

  • Die vivosmart5 hat IMHO kein eingebautes GPS, sondern nutzt die Daten vom Smartphone. Das wäre für mich der Schritt zur vivoactive5. Allerdings haben beide kein barometrischen Höhenmesser, was die Erkennung von z.B. Treppensteigen unmöglich macht und die Höhenangaben zu den Aktivitäten ungenau macht. Falls die Höhe eine Rolle spielt, sollte es eher die Venu3 werden. Finanziell attraktiv wäre wohl die Vivoactive4 wenn es kein AMOLED sein muss, oder ansonsten die Venu2.
    Garmin | Product Compare