This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

GC: Workouts: duration parameter: HR BUG

Workouts in Garmin Connect:
If HR is chosen as parameter for duration, it is the HR< parameter.
That means it only checks if the HR is smaller than the target HR (which is always the case, i.e. during warmup, or when speeding up to reach a certain HR anywy).
With the effect that such a step goal is always fullfilled and immediately the next step in the workout will be activated.

Workout example in Garmin Connect:
step1:
duration = HR 120 BPM
target = none

Which is created as HR < 120 BPM, target: none

Effect on Edge500: if HR < 120 BPM next step

Garmin Connect indicates an error, if the operator <> is added to the BPM number in the value field.


But if workouts are created directly on the device, all the options are available, i.e.:
HR >
HR <

So currenctly maybe the best workout feature, to train according to HR, is severely crippled by GC, because it only allows to define a duration PLUS HR-intervals, which is bad, because it doesn't allow to create a workout that checks, if the lower bound of the next HR-zone has been reached, before the next step with the duration in this HR zone becomes activated. To use this feature, workouts must be created directly on the Edge 500 (maybe the same with other devices).
But this feature ROCKS - but cannot be used via GC.
  • Agreed - it is frustrating - however this type of workout can also be created in Training Centre which can still be downloaded for free - it is then slightly easier to create the workouts rather than directly on the device
  • Hi,
    yes I downloaded Training Centre already. But I must say for the tiny device with only four buttons, the concept how they are created and how they can be edited is marvellous. The real damage is created by Garmin Connect which suggests that this fantastic feature does not work or is not there and only time could be used as target-parameter.

    Even DCRainmaker in his Edge 500 review only mentiones the GC workouts with duration as parameter. :o