This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Why is TSS different Garmin Versus TrainingPeaks

Former Member
Former Member
I have uploaded the same workout to Garmin Connect and TrainingPeaks but they show different NP, IF, and TSS.

My threshold is set the same in both so what would be causing this?

Thanks
Gerrard
  • Different methodologies I suspect. Interesting to note that Garmin refer you to training peaks for an explanation - support.garmin.com/.../case.faces

    But that still does not go anywhere to explain why the difference. You need to get hold of the underlying algorithms in order to see the difference. TP seem a little more open in that respect.
  • Except that I would have thought that Garmin would have licensed from PeaksWare not only the trademarked terms TSS, NP and IF, but also the underlying algorithms for computing those metrics. I would have thought this ... but evidently I would have been incorrect in thinking this.
  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 10 years ago
    Yeah I would have assumed the algorithm for TSS would be same anywhere otherwise it's couldn't be TSS which is trademarked.
  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 10 years ago
    For those interested - it was because I was excluding zeros from power averaging on the Garmin 910. Have changed that now and it all matches very closely.
  • That's good to know. Thanks.

    Just for interest really, although the algorithms may be the same the information transferred might be different depending on what is passed. Just done some research with 910s and 310s and found the distances recorded by GPS were consistently higher than a measured wheel (from 60 GPS samples). We would have anticipated a normal distribution either side of the mean wheel measure. We've not analysed the csv files yet but there may be some indication in there.

    As I said, interesting but not necessarily relevant
  • Seven years later and still helpful.

    Thanks!