This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Should I buy the 550t

Former Member
Former Member
Pls excuse if this is not the correct forum. I need some help in making a purchase decision. I am trying to decide whether to buy the 550t. I am not familiar with mapping gps units, but I do have a keen interest in gps technology.

At present, I own an old etrex, a Tomtom for the car (received as a present), and I have the Forerunner 305 on order. I learned to land/navigate with a map, compass, and protractor. My main interest is photography and I am a nut regarding geotagging. I own a Nikon P6000 point and shoot with a weak gps receiver, and I also own the Nikon GP-1 gps receiver that attaches to my dSLR cameras (very happy with this). I use Lightroom which allows me to pull up a map of geocoded photos. Much of the time navigating back to an old photo is easy (not far off of a road); however, sometimes it is more difficult (ex. in the marsh or finding a particular tomb in a New Orleans cemetery). I often visit locations taking lots of pictures as a “reconnoiter” photo shoot, with the intention of bringing heavier equipment later to do a more formal and static shoot (pro lenses, tripods, light stands, pelican cases, etc.). Thus I want a GPS unit where I can enter long and lat as waypoints, if geotagged with the Nikon GP-1.

I have a Droid Incredible on order and it has GPS too. The research I’ve done on the droid is that it has a pretty good gps receiver, but the maps are not resident to the smartphone itself, so if I’m in the woods (will be in the NC mountains next month) I may get a location without a map (can still breadcrumb my way home). Additionally, I hear that gps usage on the droid is a strain on the battery. Of course the droid will not be nearly as robust as an Oregon, which is also a factor.

I don’t expect to be in the wilderness, but a few times per year. Most of those treks will be in south Louisiana which is pretty darned flat. Additionally, I have a second job as a police officer and most of us like to have a gps unit handy. I think a robust unit could come in handy for some of those situations (rain, getting knocked around in the car, etc.). Also, I’m active in our local emergency response team, which could involve some light search and rescue (we are not Alaska afterall).

I like the idea of the 550t’s camera (albeit it is very limited) due to my photography. Both it and the droid will geotag and have gps maps. So, not being made of money, I’m trying to decide. I’ve looked at lots of reviews and they are only so helpful. Other than what I’ve mentioned, what will the 550t do for me that the droid will not and based on the above activities, would you do the deal? I’m not opposed to spending the money on the 550t, even at that price, I just want to know if this makes sense for me. Thanks.
  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 14 years ago
    You need to decide what are your priorities for the device based on their individual strengths. No one device is going to be good at all functions.

    The P6000: Excellent camera, weak GPS (no map), no phone

    Droid Incredible: Excellent smart phone, weak GPS (sometimes no map), weak camera

    Oregon 550T: Excellent GPS (always map), weak camera, no phone

    What is more important to YOU!.
  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 14 years ago
    Pls excuse if this is not the correct forum. I need some help in making a purchase decision. I am trying to decide whether to buy the 550t. I am not familiar with mapping gps units, but I do have a keen interest in gps technology.

    At present, I own an old etrex, a Tomtom for the car (received as a present), and I have the Forerunner 305 on order. I learned to land/navigate with a map, compass, and protractor. My main interest is photography and I am a nut regarding geotagging. I own a Nikon P6000 point and shoot with a weak gps receiver, and I also own the Nikon GP-1 gps receiver that attaches to my dSLR cameras (very happy with this). I use Lightroom which allows me to pull up a map of geocoded photos. Much of the time navigating back to an old photo is easy (not far off of a road); however, sometimes it is more difficult (ex. in the marsh or finding a particular tomb in a New Orleans cemetery). I often visit locations taking lots of pictures as a “reconnoiter” photo shoot, with the intention of bringing heavier equipment later to do a more formal and static shoot (pro lenses, tripods, light stands, pelican cases, etc.). Thus I want a GPS unit where I can enter long and lat as waypoints, if geotagged with the Nikon GP-1.

    I have a Droid Incredible on order and it has GPS too. The research I’ve done on the droid is that it has a pretty good gps receiver, but the maps are not resident to the smartphone itself, so if I’m in the woods (will be in the NC mountains next month) I may get a location without a map (can still breadcrumb my way home). Additionally, I hear that gps usage on the droid is a strain on the battery. Of course the droid will not be nearly as robust as an Oregon, which is also a factor.

    I don’t expect to be in the wilderness, but a few times per year. Most of those treks will be in south Louisiana which is pretty darned flat. Additionally, I have a second job as a police officer and most of us like to have a gps unit handy. I think a robust unit could come in handy for some of those situations (rain, getting knocked around in the car, etc.). Also, I’m active in our local emergency response team, which could involve some light search and rescue (we are not Alaska afterall).

    I like the idea of the 550t’s camera (albeit it is very limited) due to my photography. Both it and the droid will geotag and have gps maps. So, not being made of money, I’m trying to decide. I’ve looked at lots of reviews and they are only so helpful. Other than what I’ve mentioned, what will the 550t do for me that the droid will not and based on the above activities, would you do the deal? I’m not opposed to spending the money on the 550t, even at that price, I just want to know if this makes sense for me. Thanks.


    You will get a different answer from those people whom have purchased the 550T in the UK. I own a 550T and its a good unit (overall). However, Garmin have mislead the public in saying it is WAAS/EGNOS enabled.. more like WAAS/EGNOS crippled! My unit reports 0% accuracy at 2-3m and not the 95% accuracy Garmin claim. The real accuracy of the GPS is more like 10-15m 95% of the time. This is a view that is shared by a good many 550T users I know and from the Wiki pages on the Internet.

    I too am a working photogapher and I will admit that this unit is reliable enough to get me back to an important photo point, but if absolute accuracy was required, I'd have definitely bought another device.

    550T Pros:

    Custom Mapping (though this is severely restricted)
    Relatively long Battery life (use nothing less than 2700maH batteries)
    Build quality
    IPX7 waterproof

    Cons:

    This unit cannot receive a reliable SBAS lock (WAAS/EGNOS) - Doesn't work basically.
    Screen difficult to read on overcast days
    Buggy firmware (though its very slowly getting better)