Edge 130 Resting Calories Very Low

I did a 70 km ride yesterday that took about 3 hours 40 minutes, tracked on my Edge 130 Plus. The estimated calories burned for the ride was 158 (34 resting, 124 active). This seems outrageously low to me, particularly the resting calories. That works out to less than 10 calories per hour!

In contrast, I tracked a Zwift ride on my Instinct 2S watch (as an indoor cycling activity) and it estimated 115 calories for a 1h45 activity, which works out to about 65 cal/hour. This seems reasonable to me, and it's consistent across a few other activity types I've tracked recently with my watch (swimming, running, yoga). 

I checked my birth date, weight, height, and gender in the settings for both devices, they're identical. I used the same HRM for both rides. I don't use a power meter for outdoor rides, but I have power readings from a Wahoo trainer for indoor rides. I don't think power or heart rate should affect resting calories anyway, though. 

I also looked back at some rides since I got the Edge a couple months ago, and up until around May 20th the resting calories were also about 65 cal/hour, but it looks like sometime after that it dropped to about 33-35 resting cal no matter how long the ride is. Most of my rides have been 2 hours+ but i would think there should be a difference between 2 hours and 3 hours 40!

  • I spent all day in a bikepark, max HR 161, average HR 122, 156 jupms, 35km downhill including a few uphills a guess what? 22 resting callories and 26 active callories JoyJoyJoy

  • I spent all day in a bikepark, max HR 161, average HR 122, 156 jupms, 35km downhill including a few uphills a guess what? 22 resting callories and 26 active callories JoyJoyJoy

  • Did you pause your Edge early on, by any chance? I think that’s the issue. I often go on group rides where I ride to the meetup point, then pause my Edge until we’re ready to take off, then resume.

    I logged some rides in parallel on both my Edge and my Instinct 2S watch (indoor and outdoor, using a smart trainer with power data for the indoor, and a chest HRM for all rides) and got nearly identical calories with both devices unless I paused the Edge. If I did that, it seemed to stop counting calories after I resumed, so the numbers were drastically different. The resting calories from the Edge correspond pretty closely to the duration before I paused.

    I contacted support, the passed me up the food chain to engineering. Haven’t heard anything more, but I think this is a bug they’ll have to sort out in the software.