The issue: My Instinct 2 would start pairing fine in Garmin Connect — Bluetooth confirmation code worked, watch showed "Accessory paired" — but then the app would spin indefinitely and eventually fail with "Pairing failed, Instinct 2 unable to pair your Garmin device." Retrying, the app couldn't even find the watch anymore. Oddly, phone notifications still showed up on the watch during all of this, so the Bluetooth connection itself was clearly working — just the Connect app's own registration step was hanging.
What didn't fix it (in case it saves someone else the time):
- Two firmware updates
- Removing the device from connect.garmin.com and re-pairing
- Fully uninstalling/reinstalling Garmin Connect
- Clearing the Bluetooth pairing at the phone's OS level
- A full factory reset of the watch
What actually fixed it: Uninstalling the Garmin Golf app from my phone. Paired successfully on the very next attempt, no other changes.
Likely cause: Garmin's companion apps (Connect, Golf, Dive, etc.) appear to share login/auth tokens through the phone's secure storage rather than each app managing its own session. My best guess (not confirmed by Garmin) is that Golf was holding a stale token that caused Connect to hang while trying to register the watch, even though the Bluetooth handshake itself completed fine. If you have Garmin Golf (or possibly Dive/other Garmin companion apps) installed and are hitting this exact symptom, try removing it before you burn time on factory resets.