Garmin Nutrition Auto Adjust Calorie Goal BUG

I am experiencing an issue with the Auto Adjust Calorie Goal feature in Garmin Connect Nutrition. It adds my daily active calories to a baseline target that already includes an allowance for activity (the target is calculated based on my average calories), resulting in an intake recommendation above my estimated expenditure despite my 0.25 kg/week weight-loss goal.

I read on another thread that this is an issue other users have experienced, and you wrote back 7 months ago that it should be fixed now, but it's not for me. I'm using a Garmin Epix Gen 2, and I have the latest updates for both the watch and the Garmin Connect App.

I tried calling support, but they hang up after putting me on hold. I also reached out to support via the form, got an email confirmation a week ago and never received a reply.

  • Hi  what do you have set for your Activity Level in nutrition settings? Are you able to switch to Sedentary?

  • Thanks for replying.

    Yes, I’ve tried that, as suggested elsewhere in the forum, but I didn’t think it was the correct way to set it up. My current understanding is that the auto-adjust function only works correctly when the activity level is set to “Sedentary”. If “Average Active Calories” is selected instead, auto-adjust should remain off.

    Is this how the nutrition feature was coded and intended to work? I would prefer an option to use my average active calories as the baseline for my daily calorie goal, with that goal then adjusted to reflect daily variations in activity. The calculation seems straightforward, although I appreciate that implementing it may involve other considerations.

    Please let me know whether I’ve understood this correctly. Thanks.

  • Same issue here. I don‘t see what‘s the point selecting an activity level with daily average calories including training if you are not supposed to wear your wearable during these activities. I don‘t need Garmin Connect at all in the first place if this is the case.

    One should expect that Garmin Connect+ auto adjusts the activity calories based on the actual calories compared to the average calories - at least that‘s what the option button says. But instead adding the daily activity calories to the average calories makrs no sense.

    I have now set a manual activity to the lowest possible value of 1 cal so activity calories don‘t get added up to the pre set average calories. But the whole workaround is poorly documented and a user who blindly trusts the settings might unwillingly gain weight as a result.

  • If you set activity level to sedentary, you’ll get the same result but instead of 1 calorie it will start from 0, that is just your baseline. Obviously not ideal either, it’s a workaround. 

    I’ve decided to go for a fixed target based on my average active calories. I’m keeping nutrition and calories widgets side by side and it’s working okay for me. 

    I hope the system will be re-engineered in the future.