I am having the exact same problems. I have tried contacting Garmin support about the overestimation of resting calories. I believe they are calculating the RMR rather than the BMR, just as you described it. However, it doesn't make sense when the watch registers active calories throughout the day. In that way, you double count the calories. As it is now, you cannot trust the total calories. I hope they will fix the resting calories calculation, so you can choose to have the BMR instead of the RMR.