Okta notification not passing from watch to Okta Verify App

Around August 20 clicking "Yes it is me" on a notification from the Okta Verify app stopped passing that response back to the Okta Verify App on my Android Pixel 7. I also received an update for Garmin Connect around that time. I did uninstall that version of the Garmin Connect and reinstall an older version but that did not resolve the issue. I suspect the update also changed the software on the watch (VivoActive 4) as well which I do not know how to roll back. I can still respond to texts from my watch. Is this a known bug? I am seeing other Garmin watch users on the Okta forum with the same issue but no resolution. 

Watch: VivoActive 4

Watch SW Version: 8.3

Phone: Pixel 7 with Android Version 14

Garmin Connect: Currently on 5.5 (I tried rolling back to 5.2 but it didn't help)