This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Small Nit - Band Keeper

I have loved my forerunners for years but I have one small pet peeve: poor band keepers. My last three forerunners have blow their band keeper at about the year mark. At least with the 235 a replacement is sold. No luck for my 645M or my wife's Fenix (which did the same). Our local Garmin store's response is to sell a new strap ($50?!). I know you can buy 3rd party keepers on Amazon but they never seem as good - for example, no dimple that reduces slippage. Anyways, back to more important things...
  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 5 years ago

    Same here with my 935 strap which I already replaced one and I'm not happy to pay another $50. Does Garmin even monitor these forums?

    In other thoughts, are the keepers covered by the warranty? I'm about to call my retailer to ask this.

  • I had one breaking on my previous vivoactive HR and Garmin sent me a complete new strap under warranty (2 years in the EU).

  • These have the nub and should fit the stock band, though you'll have to do your own measuring.

    Quality silicone bands can be had for $20 or less. Check out the Barton Elite, for instance (also available on Amazon). It comes with double keepers, one locking. I have the red and it looks fantastic with the black and silver of the 645. It's a bit thicker and less flexible than the Garmin, but it's comfortable enough that it seldom leaves my wrist. I'd say that it's very durable and will likely outlast the watch.

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 5 years ago

    Mine broke off about 3 weeks ago too on my 645M, about 2 and a half year old. Isn't the band for 235 and 645 the same though?
    Anyways. I fell over one of Garmin's competitors forum, where people were having the same issue - no replacement for the band keeper. First post in 2016, going all the way up to 2018 with an administrator of their forum continuously saying "thank you for you feedback, we appreciate it etc etc." though, they did not introduce a band keeper replacement in 2 years time. LOL.

    Right, I will look at getting a new band keeper from Amazon or something of the sort, though I will probably buy a new band too - different colour, since I've been meaning to do that for a while anyways.

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 5 years ago

    Mine just snapped this morning, precisely at the corner where it bends. It's around 16 months old so I am a little disappointed although i worked out quite hard with my watch. 

    The dutch Garmin shop offers a new original band for €29,99 > https://buy.garmin.com/nl-NL/NL/p/552881/pn/010-11251-0Y#

    That's way less then 50 dollars although it ins't cheap for a piece of molded silicon. 

    The black version serial number is 010-11251-0Y, so maybe doing a search on the web from your state may help you find a good replacement. 

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 5 years ago in reply to Former Member

    Mine was snapped in the middle, on the long side. 

    Anyways, an update, figured I could use an O-ring as a substitute for the band keeper. Before that I used a rubber band - a green one which didn't fit much with the black band I have.

    The black O-ring fits well though and it sits at perfect tightness so I don't need to have anything "stuck" in-between the holes of the band.

    I will keep using that, see how it goes over time. After all, no one really notice the band keeper anyways. Even if they do, the O-ring looks to match the watch at any rate, so it is doubtful anyone would question the authentication of it. :D

  • This is an issue easily handled - just buy a few extra band keepers, in generic black - I've seen packs of 7 or 8, for like $6.00USD. Almost nothing. And replacement bands themselves are plentiful and cheap out there on the internet - you can get them for as little as $4 to $8USD. Again, easy to resolve.

  • THANK YOU for the recommendation of Barton Elite replacement band for Garmin 645.  I have a very small wrist and most bands swallow it.  Barton Elite provides 2, yes 2 lengths in the replacement. And fit is better than Garmin original band. 

    Andrea

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member over 4 years ago

    Check out the Barton Elite, for instance (also available on Amazon). It comes with double keepers, one locking. This is a fine replacement band. Very happy with it.

  • The keeper of my 735 broke. I decided to contact Garmin. No answer. But a few days later a mail that a keeper is on the way to me. I even found 2 keepers in the letter. They are for the 235 (I really wrote 735 in the contact formular) but they fit. So I kept them. I didn't have to pay anything.