This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Am I really that unfit Garmin????

Former Member
Former Member

I'm 46 years old male. Been a kickboxer all my life.  I can do 100 proper form press ups in a row, sometimes up to 150 if I push it.  On week days I do (every day) 100 situps in 5x sets of 20, same with squats. Press ups 5x sets of 30 normal then 5x sets of 20 in various positions ending with a stress test of my maximum which is normally between 60 and 100 when fatigued. I do x2 intense coached kickboxing sessions per week including endurance rounds on the heavy bag (minus sparring at mo due to social distancing rules). I do a two mile run every day (it's just a trainings run so I don't bother going further and I only get a 30 minute lunch break)

On weekends I take a break and do a couple of 4 mile walks.

Yet, according to Garmin and my Vivoactive 3 watch, my VO2 max is 42 - which is "fair" .... it did go up to "good" once but then dropped again after a run where I went under trees and it thought my pulse was 150 at walking pace due to poor GPS signal!   I am 100% convinced that I am fitter than that!

I am neither under nor over weight. What's going on? Why is my apparent VO2 Max so low?

  • If you run with a slower pace with your son (or without him), it shouldn't affect your VO2max negatively, because also your heart rate will be lower. VO2max is determined by the ratio of those two, taking up/downhill also into account (especially on watches with a barometric altimeter).

    Having said that, my personal experience is that the VO2max I get tends to be a couple of decimals on the low side for slow runs, and conversely higher than normally for runs where heart rate is on the high aerobic side. I've read others have similar experiences. But really those differences are <0.5 (Garmin Connect doesn't show VO2max decimals, and for a good reason, but you can get those by syncing your account to Runalyze, for example).