This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

PulsOx accuracy?

Anyone compared Garmin's PulsOx with a medical grade oximeter?

I suspect Garmin is not very good. For example, right now, my Fenix just measured 91%. When I used Samsung's app on my S9, I got 98% (measured on a finger).

On Fenix, I'm getting an average daily readings of around 93-95% but during night I see it dipping to 90 or even 85% (average about 92-93%). Seems low as I don't have any medical condition.

Could it be that for wrist measurements, it's more sensitive to position of the watch? Or blood flow through the wrist?

I don't understand, why there should be such a difference between Fenix and the phone app?

  • Fenix ​​6's pulse oximeter is inaccurate.

  • I'm also getting low readings when the watch is placed on the outer wrist where it normally are when sleeping. I'm using a Fenix 6X Pro Solar (version 11.77). I tested to do some measurements with different placements of the watch and the best reading was in a dark room and the sensor on the most inner knuckle on the index finger. Like the picture below.

  • Is funny to measure like that.

    A good pulse oximeter can be purchased with 20-25 USD. Why spend so much money on a watch ant try to make funny things just to get an accurate value of a sensor?

  • I agree, the best had been if it worked like supposed on the outer wrist. But now the watch have a sensor included and hopefully Garmin can tweak something so it works better on outer wrist.

    It could be good to know how you can get a decent reading from the sensor if its not working accurate on the outer wrist.

  • Vivosmart 4 band have the same issue.

    Nothing works as it should.

    Cheap marketing stuff.

    If you claim something all will say to you that Garmin stated that this is not a medical device bla bla.... No. Is not a medical device but this is not an excuse to not works as it should.

  • Because it integrates all things in one easy to understand platform (Connect), making analysis of trends easier.

  • If the readings are wrong the trend is wrong. That is the whole point.

  • Former Member
    +1 Former Member

    My help factory reset, now the readings are good

  • I was in a hospital three months ago and, since they had me on a pulse ox monitor (while lying on a gurney), I decided to simultaneously run my fenix pulse ox. The hospital on showed 98%, Fenix 95%. Confirmed my suspicions.

  • Former Member
    0 Former Member

    i keep waiting for a new sensor from Garmin, and waiting, and waiting.  The Elevate 3 sucks.   The Fenix 5 sensor performed better in almost every way.  I hate to do compares, but my AW6 is spot on and night-time measuring is spot on.