This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Open water distance issues

So my second open water swim and the save issue, distance is way off, being much longer distance,  as much as 1000 yards extra. The track is close to spot on but the distance is ridiculously high. The image attached is on my first open water swim. along the path i swam is also a measured boardwalk being .75 miles in length. I swam just short of that length x 2, say around 1.2 miles. If you look at scale on the map in concurs with about 1.2 miles. However the total distance calculated by garmin is 3623 yards which is 2 miles. No way i swam two miles. I will probably call garmin but i wonder if anyone else is having this issue. Even though i have had this watch since around Nov, being in NY i just started open water swims and unfortunately its useless. 

  • Today I did another swim using a Fenix 6x pro and a Suunto 9 baro with a HR chest band. I set GPS recording to 1s (and not intelligent as in the default setting). Both watches used GPS+Glonas.

    Here‘s what was recorded by Suunto:

  • Today I did another OWS using a Suunto 9 baro and a Fenix 6x pro. Both watches use GPS + Glonass. Fenix was set to 1s GPS recording (and nit the default intelligent mode).

    Distance is about 1500 m, previous training where done with the Suunto 9 and more or less confirmed distance.

    Here‘s recording with the Fenix:

    and here what was recorded by Suunto:

    I‘m quite satisfied with what was recorded by the fenix, compared to previous tests where the Fenix was adding a considerable amount of ghost distance! I guess the trick was changing to 1s GPS recording. The GPS track looks quite nice and a bit smoother compared to the Suunto (for example, seen at the turning point).

  • Was that the only change? mine was already set to one sec recordings

  • That was the only change I made. Will test more to see if it is consistent, but I‘m optimistic.

  • I give up. Today I swam a clean free style the whole time, no idle, no stop.  It seemed like I was getting my 500 yards vibrate fine for the first 1500 yards. Then at 1500 yards I turned around and within one minute I got another vibrate.  Sure enough upon looking at the watch it was now at 2000 yards.  I had one second, GPS + Glonass, soaked for about 5 minutes. This time I also brought the 6x Saphire set to run mode and placed in my buoy. 

    Here is the Saphire (set to run mode in my buoy) track and distance, which is correct.

    And Here is the data on my 6x Pro worn on my left wrist.

  • Looks like this is a real issue and the boys on the FR945 forerunner forum are discussing it as well.  One insight from that forum which I definitely agree with is that it seems like when there is poor GPS signal they use the accelerometer for distance, but then when they pick up a GPS signal they add that distance to the total sum which is why we end up with a much longer swim.  Here is the link to the 945 forum.  They also suggest that a fix is coming.  

    https://forums.garmin.com/sports-fitness/running-multisport/f/forerunner-945/212149/open-water-swim-fr945-settings

    And here, the same issue is being discussed on the SWIM2 forum

    https://forums.garmin.com/sports-fitness/running-multisport/f/garmin-swim-2/214105/gps-open-water-error

    And, if you head over to the SWIM2 Forum you will see that the beta SW attempts to address the open water swim distance issue.  I am hopeful that this fix will make it our way.  See below for the SWIM2 fix, 4th bullet

    Changes made from version 2.30 to 2.33:

    • Fix crash related to CIQ watchface
    • Fix issue that could cause Statue/Metric and 12-hour/24-hour time settings to not be correctly honored after a software update
    • Improve Bluetooth connection stability
    • Improve open water distance
    • Fix auto lock feature
    • Add alerts for abnormally low heart rate
    • Fix issue that could prevent the backlight from turning on when an alarm is triggered
    • Fix weekly swim totals being incorrect
    • Fix 33 1/3 pool length personal records
    • Make auto lap distance configurable for open water
    • Fix repeated distance/time alerts issue
    • Update for CIQ security
  • Good day all!

    I also encounter much longer distances being recorded by the 6x pro v.s. my mobile and Garmin GPSmap 60 CSx. But what strikes me most is that the tracks from the 6x pro are very accurate however there is some sort of distance translation made in the watch showing a much greater distance.

    When I export the track from the Fenix to MapSource, and compare it with the tracks from the other devices, the distances are very similar.

    Time to go to work Garmin people and give us what we pay for ;)

  • Have you tried this app for ows? 

    Perhaps it is better than the native app from garmin? 

    Garmin Connect IQ Store apps.garmin.com/.../822d7118-a687-46ce-83c4-514764400171

    Or that one: 

    apps.garmin.com/.../3ae9729f-c364-451b-9ca4-ca540749f6e7

    • On a OW swim today my random number generator came up with 3800 yards on a swim that was around 2250 yards. And unfortunately for me i brought my 910xt (to measure distance) which was tracking distance accurately,  until the band broke and the water kept the 910xt Disappointed
  • I have just bought a Polar Grit X because to me it was too strange that my pace it had gotten worse so much! 

    Here you are, Fenix 6x Solar on the left hand and Polar Grit X on the right hand : judge for yourself!

    Distance is off by 579m and obviously pace is off!

    Also HR reading is wrong, but this is another story.